Economics Volume II: Modern Economic ProblemsFetter, Frank A. (Frank Albert)
General
Economics Volume II: Modern Economic Problems
Fetter, Frank A. (Frank Albert)
Economics
income. This involves a burden that is ruinous in some cases, both to
borrowers and to lenders, and that tempts in all cases to the evasion
of the tax.
Take, for example, a house assessed at $10,000 which is owned free of
debt and which has a rental value of $600. At the rate of 1.5 per cent
the tax paid would be $150. Now if the owner borrows $8000 he is still
taxable $150 on the full value of the house, and the lender nearly
everywhere is taxable $120 on the amount of his mortgage. The total
tax payable out of the one source of income, the house, is then $270.
The same analysis will show that any credit is but a contractual
claim upon some other source of income which is, or should have been,
already taxed.
If one person owns all the capital-value invested in a specific piece
of wealth, no attempt is made to tax both the capital and the wealth;
but if it happens that two or more persons share the capital-value
invested in the same wealth, the attempt is made to tax as a unit the
full value of the wealth and, in addition, some part of the capital
also. It is, however, easy in most cases to conceal this "intangible
property" from the assessor's eyes, and a comparatively small amount
of it is ever taxed. This means inequality and hardship in the
operation of the tax and, as a result, unceasing temptation to perjury
by the taxpayer and to favoritism and graft by public officials.
§ 4. #Various temporizing policies.# The general property tax in
practice is unjust and demoralizing. What, then, shall be done about
it? Various policies have been followed. One has been to declare that
the law would be good if it could be enforced, but that as in practice
it cannot be, the best thing is to go on as before, catching a few
"tax dodgers," and letting the rest go. Another policy is to hire
"tax ferrets," paying them large commissions to discover cases
where intangible property of this sort has been concealed from the
assessors. This method, no matter how stringently applied, has never
reached more than a small proportion of the cases, and becomes a
potent agency of political favoritism and corruption.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account