EINSTEIN’S SOLUTION
_Provisional rejection of ether—Relativist
interpretation of Michelson’s experiment—New aspect
of the speed of light—Explanation of the contraction
of moving bodies—Time and the four dimensions of
space—Einstein’s “Interval” the only material reality._
Einstein’s first act of intelligent audacity was that, without
relegating the ether to the category of those obsolete fluids, such as
phlogiston and animal spirits, which obstructed the avenues of science
until Lavoisier appeared—without denying all reality to ether, for
there must be some sort of support for the rays which reach us from the
sun—he observed that, in all that we have as yet seen, there is always
question of velocities relatively to the ether.
We have no means whatever of establishing such velocities, and perhaps
it would be simpler to leave out of our arguments this entity, real
or otherwise, which is inaccessible and merely plays the futile and
troublesome part of fifth wheel to the electro-magnetic chariot in the
progress of physicists along the ruts of their difficulties.
The first point is then: Einstein begins, provisionally, by omitting
the ether from his line of reasoning. He neither denies nor affirms its
existence. He begins by ignoring it.
We will now follow his example. We shall no longer, in the course of
our demonstration, speak about the medium in which light travels. We
shall consider light only in relation to the beings or material objects
which emit or receive it. We shall find that our progress becomes at
once much easier. For the moment we will relegate the ether of the
physicists to the store of useless accessories, along with the suave,
formless, vague—but so precious artistically—ether of the poets.
* * * * *
Shortly, what does Michelson’s experiment prove? Only that a ray of
light travels at the surface of the earth from west to east at exactly
the same speed as from east to west. Let us imagine two similar guns in
the middle of a plain, both firing at the same moment, in calm weather,
and discharging their shells with the same initial velocity, but one
toward the west and the other toward the east. It is clear that the two
shells will take the same time to traverse an equal amount of space,
one going toward the west and the other toward the east. The rays of
light which we produce on the earth behave in this respect, as regards
their progress, exactly as the shells do. There would therefore be
nothing surprising in the result of the Michelson experiment, if we
knew only what experience tells us about the luminous rays.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account