Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Philosophy
Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000
Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Relativity (Physics)
[Moreover, if we remove the veil from our window to the extent that
we may observe the train on the adjoining track, we shall be able to
make no decision as to whether we or it be moving. This is indeed an
experience which we have all had.]* [Often when seated in a train
about to leave the station, we have thought ourselves under way,
only to perceive as the motion becomes no longer uniform that another
train has been backing into the station on the adjoining track. Again,
as we were hurried on our journey, we have, raising suddenly our eyes,
been puzzled to say whether the passing train were moving with us or
against us or indeed standing still; or more rarely we have had the
impression that both it and we seemed to be at rest, when in truth
both were moving rapidly with the same speed.]82 [Even this phrase "in
truth" is a relative one, for it arises through using the earth as an
absolute reference body. We are indeed naive if we cannot appreciate
that there is no reason for doing this beyond convenience, and that
to an observer detached from the earth it were just as reasonable
to say that the rails are sliding under the train as that the train
is advancing along the rails. One of my own most vivid childhood
recollections is of the terror with which, riding on a train that
passed through a narrow cut, I hid my head in the maternal lap to shut
out the horrid sight of the earth rushing past my window. The absence
of a background in relatively slow retrograde motion was sufficient
to prevent my consciousness from drawing the accustomed conclusion
that after all it was really the train that was moving.]*
MECHANICAL RELATIVITY
[So we can enunciate the following principle: When a body is in
uniform rectilinear motion relatively to a second body, then all
phenomena take place on the first in exactly the same manner as on
the second; the physical laws for the happenings on both bodies are
identical.]24 [And between a system of bodies, nothing but relative
motion may be detected by any mechanical means whatever; any attempt
to discuss absolute motion presupposes a super-observer on some body
external to the system. Even then, the "absolute" motion is nothing
but motion relative to this super-observer. By no mechanical means
is uniform straight-line motion of any other than relative character
to be detected. This is the Principle of Mechanical Relativity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account