Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Philosophy
Einstein's Theories of Relativity and Gravitation: A selection of material from the essays submitted in the competition for the Eugene Higgins prize of $5,000
Bird, J. Malcolm (James Malcolm)
Relativity (Physics)
[As a fair example, see what the acceptance of the earth's sphericity
did to the idea represented by the word "down." With a flat earth,
"down" is a single direction, the same throughout the universe; with
a round earth, "down" becomes merely the direction leading toward
the center of the particular heavenly body on which we happen to be
located. It is so with every concept we have. No matter how intrinsic
a part of nature and of our being a certain notion may seem, we can
never know that new facts will not develop which will show it to be a
mistaken one. Today we are merely confronted by a gigantic example of
this sort of thing. Einstein tells us that when velocities are attained
which have just now come within the range of our close investigation,
extraordinary things happen--things quite irreconcilable with our
present concepts of time and space and mass and dimension. We are
tempted to laugh at him, to tell him that the phenomena he suggests
are absurd because they contradict these concepts. Nothing could be
more rash than this.
When we consider the results which follow from physical velocities
comparable with that of light, we must confess that here are
conditions which have never before been carefully investigated. We
must be quite as well prepared to have these conditions reveal some
epoch-making fact as was Galileo when he turned the first telescope
upon the skies. And if this fact requires that we discard present
ideas of time and space and mass and dimension, we must be prepared
to do so quite as thoroughly as our medieval fathers had to discard
their notions of celestial "perfection" which demanded that there
be but seven major heavenly bodies and that everything center about
the earth as a common universal hub. We must be prepared to revise
our concepts of these or any other fundamentals quite as severely as
did the first philosopher who realized that "down" in London was not
parallel to "down" in Bagdad or on Mars.]*
[In all ordinary terrestrial matters we take the earth as a fixed
body, light as instantaneous. This is perfectly proper, for such
matters. But we carry our earth-acquired habits with us into the
celestial regions. Though we have no longer the earth to stand on,
yet we assume, as on the earth, that all measurements and movements
must be referred to some fixed body, and are only then valid. We cling
to our earth-bound notion that there is an absolute up-and-down,
back-and-forth, right-and-left, in space. We may admit that we can
never find it, but we still think it is there, and seek to approach
it as nearly as possible. And similarly from our earth experiences,
which are sufficiently in a single place to make possible this
simplifying assumption, we get the idea that there is one universal
time, applicable at once to the entire universe.]141 [The difficulty
in accepting Einstein is entirely the difficulty in getting away from
these earth-bound habits of thought.]*
IV
THE SPECIAL THEORY OF RELATIVITY
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account