Elements of metaphysicsTaylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Philosophy
Elements of metaphysics
Taylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Metaphysics
When we forget this and treat any partial experience as though it were
the complete and adequate expression of the whole nature of Reality,—in
other words, when we try to apply to existence or the universe as a
whole conceptions which are only valid for special aspects of
existence,—we shall inevitably find ourselves led to contradictory and
absurd results. Each partial aspect of a total system can only be
ultimately understood by reference to the whole to which it belongs, and
hence any attempt to treat the part in abstraction as itself a
self-contained whole,—or, in other words, to treat the concepts with
which we have to work in dealing with some special aspect of the world
of experience as ultimately valid in their application to the whole
system,—is bound to issue in contradiction. Again, just because our
knowledge of the structure of the system as a whole is so imperfect as
it is, our insight into the structure of its constituents is also
necessarily limited. Hence it will commonly happen that, even within the
limits of their applicability, the special concepts of our various
sciences are not, when thought out, free from internal contradiction.
For instance, we are led to absurd results when we try, as Materialism
does, to interpret the whole system of experience in terms of the
concepts used in the purely physical sciences; and again, even in their
restricted use as physical categories, these concepts seem incapable of
being so defined as to involve no element of contradiction.
In both these senses all Appearance implies an element of contradiction;
only for an insight which could take in at once the whole system of
existence would its details be completely coherent and harmonious. But
this does not alter the fact that, so far as our insight into any part
of the whole and its connection with other parts is self-consistent, it
does convey genuine, though imperfect, knowledge of the whole. Though
our detailed insight into the structure of the whole may never reach the
ideal of perfect self-consistency, yet it may approximate to that ideal
in different degrees, at different stages, or with reference to
different aspects. And the closer the approximation the less the
modification which our knowledge would require to bring it into complete
harmony with itself, and the greater therefore the element of truth
about Reality which it contains.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account