Elements of metaphysicsTaylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Philosophy
Elements of metaphysics
Taylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Metaphysics
(1) Cause and effect must be strictly correlative. For to say that there
may be variations in the cause not followed by corresponding variations
in the effect, is to say that there can be conditions which condition
nothing; and to admit variation in the effect without variation in the
cause, is to allow that there are occurrences which are at once, as
effects, determined, and yet again are not determined, by the assemblage
of their antecedents. Thus Plurality of Causes is excluded by the very
conception of a cause as the totality of conditions. Following up this
line of thought further, we see that it leads to a perplexing result.
The “totality of conditions” is never a real totality. For there are no
such things as isolated effects and causes in the world of events. The
whole fact which we call an effect is never complete until we have taken
into account its entire connection with everything else in the universe.
And similarly, the whole assemblage of conditions includes everything
which goes to make up the universe. But when we have thus widened our
conception of the cause and the effect, both cause and effect have
become identical with one another and with the whole contents of the
universe. And thus Causation itself has disappeared as a form of
interconnection between the elements of Reality in our attempt to work
out its logical implications.
This is an inevitable consequence of the continuous interconnection of
all Reality established by our examination of the problem of the One and
the Many in Chapter II. In other words, you never have reached the full
cause of any event until you have taken into account the _totality_ of
its conditions, _i.e._ the totality of its connections with all the rest
of existence. But this totality cannot be obtained in the form
presupposed by the phrase “totality of conditions” as a plurality of
events. For to obtain it in this fashion would mean to sum an infinite
series. But when you abandon the form of the infinite series, cause and
effect alike become identical with the systematic whole of Reality.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account