Elements of metaphysicsTaylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Philosophy
Elements of metaphysics
Taylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Metaphysics
§ 4. We may now apply the results obtained in the previous section to
the general question as to the “independent” existence of the physical
order. In doing so we observe two consequences of the highest
importance. (1) Now that we have found that at least a part of that
order, namely, the bodies of our fellow-men, are not mere complexes of
presentations in our own experience, but have a further existence as
themselves experiencing subjects, and are so far “independent” of their
actual presentation in our own experience, we can no longer conclude,
from the dependence of the physical order for its sensible properties
upon presentation to ourselves, that it has no further existence of its
own. If one part of that order, which as presented stands on the same
footing with the rest, and is, like it, dependent on presentation for
its sensible properties, is certainly known to be more than a mere
presentation-complex, the same _may_ at least be true of other parts. We
can no longer assert of any part of the physical order, without special
proof, that its _esse_ is merely _percipi_.
We may go a step further. Not only _may_ other parts of the physical
order possess a reality beyond the mere fact of being presented to our
sense-perception, but they _must_. For (_a_) we have to take note, for
the obtaining of our own practical ends, of the factors in our
_material_ environment precisely as we have to take note of the
purposive behaviour not our own which forms our _social_ environment.
Just as our own inner life has no coherent significance except as part
of a wider whole of purposive human life, so human society as a system
of significant conduct directed to the attainment of ends, cannot be
understood without reference to its non-human surroundings and
conditions. To understand my own experience, reference must be made to
the aims, ideals, beliefs, etc. of the social whole in which I am a
member; and to understand these, reference has again to be made to
geographical, climatic, economical, and other conditions. Thus of the
physical order at large, no less than of that special part of it which
consists of the bodies of my fellows, it is true to say that its
existence means a great deal more than the fact of its presentation.
Unperceived physical existence must be real if I am myself real, because
my own inner life is unintelligible without reference to it.
(_b_) This conclusion is further strengthened by the evidence supplied
by the various sciences, that human life forms part of a great system
characterised by evolution or development. If one part of a connected
historical development is more than a complex of presentations, the
other stages of that development cannot possibly be mere
presentation-complexes. Against any “Idealism” which is mere
Subjectivism or Presentationism calling itself by a less suspicious
name, it would be a sound and fair argument to contend that it reduces
evolution to a dream, and must therefore be false.[123]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account