Elements of metaphysicsTaylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Philosophy
Elements of metaphysics
Taylor, A. E. (Alfred Edward)
Metaphysics
Indeed, it is obvious from first principles that when the sets of terms
between which a number of relations of the same type holds are
indistinguishable, the relations cannot be discriminated. To distinguish
directions at all, we must, in the end, take at least our starting-point
and one or more standard directions reckoned from it—according to the
number of dimensions with which we are dealing—as independently given,
that is, as having recognisable qualitative differences from other
possible starting-points and standard directions. (Thus, to distinguish
before and after in conceptual time, you must at least assume some
moment of time, qualitatively recognisable from others, as the epoch
from which you reckon, and must also have some recognisable qualitative
distinction between the direction “past” and the direction “future.”)
And with this reference to qualitative differences we are at once thrown
back, as in the case of perceptual time and space, on the insoluble old
problem of Quality and Relation. The assumed starting-point and standard
directions _must_ have qualitative individuality, or they could not be
independently recognised and made the basis for discrimination between
the remaining directions and positions: yet, because of the necessary
homogeneity of the space and time of conceptual construction, they
_cannot_ have any such qualitative individuality, but must be
_arbitrarily_ assumed. They will therefore themselves be capable of
determination only by reference to some other equally arbitrary
standard, and thus we are once more committed to the indefinite regress.
The practical usefulness of these constructions thus depends on the very
fact that we are not consistent in our use of them. In all practical
applications we use them to map out the spatial and temporal order of
events as seen in perspective from a standpoint which is, as regards the
conceptual time and space order itself, arbitrary and indistinguishable
from others.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account