Elements of Morals: With Special Application of the Moral Law to the Duties of the Individual and of Society and the StateJanet, Paul
Philosophy
Elements of Morals: With Special Application of the Moral Law to the Duties of the Individual and of Society and the State
Janet, Paul
Ethics
(_a_) The first is _assumed superiority_, that is to say an imperious
manner in the expression of one's sentiments, and which most persons
resent, as much because it shows a proud and haughty soul, as because
it indicates a domineering spirit tyrannizing over minds.
(_b_) The second is the decided and dogmatic manner in which an
opinion is given; as if it could not be reasonably contradicted.
(_c_) _Vehemence_ does not belong to the mistakes we have just spoken
of. It consists in conveying the impression that one is not only
attached to one's sentiments from conviction, but also passionately,
which furnishes many people a reason for suspecting the truth of those
sentiments, thus inspiring in them a wholly contrary feeling.
(_d_) The contempt and insults which enter into disputes, are so
obviously shocking, that it is not necessary to warn against them; but
it may be well to remark that there are certain rudenesses and
incivilities nearly akin to contempt, although they spring from
another source. Change of opinion is in itself such a hard thing, and
so contrary to nature, that we must not add to it other difficulties.
(_e_) Finally, _hardness_, which does not so much consist in the
hardness of the terms employed as in the absence of certain softening
words, also often shocks those thus addressed, because it implies a
sort of indifference and contempt.
2. _Passions._--It is not enough to avoid contradicting people's opinions,
or to do so cautiously only; one must also spare their _inclinations_ and
their _passions_, because otherwise, it is impossible to avoid complaints,
murmurs, and quarrels.
These inclinations are of three kinds: which may be called _just_,
_indifferent_, and _unjust_.
(_a_) One should never really satisfy the unjust ones; but it is not
always necessary to oppose them; for it is wounding others to make
one's self conspicuous without particular reason.... One must always
make amends for good and evil ... especially when there are others who
could do it with better results than we.
Besides, "this same rule obliges us to choose the least offensive, the
gentlest, the least irritating means."
(_b_) I call indifferent passions those the objects of which are not
bad in themselves, although they may be sought after with a vicious
adhesion. Now, in this sort of things we are at greater liberty to
yield to the inclinations of others: 1, because we are not their
judges; 2, because we do not know whether these affections are not
necessary to them (leading them away from still more dangerous
objects); 3, because these sorts of affections must be destroyed with
prudence and circumspection; 4, because there is reason to fear we
might do them more harm in indirectly opposing their innocent
passions, than we should do them good in warning them against them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account