globe in consolidating the sedimentary rocks, and believed that molten
material from the earth's interior has been protruded from below into
the overlying crust. Some of the material thus injected could be
recognized, he thought, in granite and in the various dark massive
rocks which, known in Scotland under the name of "whinstone," were
afterwards called "Trap," and are now grouped under various names,
such as basalt, dolerite and diorite. So important a share did Hutton
thus assign to the internal heat in the geological evolution of the
planet, that he and those who adopted the same opinions were styled
"Plutonists," or, especially where they concerned themselves with the
volcanic origin of basalt, "Vulcanists." The geological world was thus
divided into two hostile camps, that of the Neptunists or Wernerians,
and that of the Plutonists, Vulcanists or Huttonians.
After many years of futile controversy the first serious weakening of
the position of the dominant Neptunist school arose from the defection
of some of the most prominent of Werner's pupils. In particular Jean
Francois D'Aubuisson de Voisins (1769-1819), who had written a
treatise on the aqueous origin of the basalts of Saxony, went
afterwards to Auvergne, where he was speedily a convert to the views
expounded by Desmarest as to the volcanic nature of basalt. Having
thus to relinquish one of the fundamental articles of the Freiberg
faith, he was subsequently led to modify his adherence to others
until, as he himself confessed, his views came almost wholly to agree
with those of Hutton. Not less complete, and even more important, was
the conversion of the great Leopold von Buch (1774-1853). He, too, was
trained by Werner himself, and proved to be the most illustrious pupil
of the Saxon professor. Full of admiration for the Neptunism in which
he had been reared, he, in his earliest separate work, maintained the
aqueous origin of basalt, and contrasted the wide field opened up to
the spirit of observation by his master's teaching with the narrower
outlook offered by "the volcanic theory." But a little further
acquaintance with the facts of nature led Von Buch also to abandon his
earlier prepossessions. It was a personal visit to the volcanic region
of Auvergne that first opened his eyes, and led him to recant what he
had believed and written about basalt. But the abandonment of so
essential a portion of the Wernerian creed prepared the way for
further relinquishments. When a few years later he went to Norway and
found to his astonishment that granite, which he had been taught to
regard as the oldest chemical precipitate from the universal ocean,
could there be seen to have broken through and metamorphosed
fossiliferous limestones, and to have sent veins into them, his faith
in Werner's order of the succession of the rocks in the earth's crust
received a further momentous shock.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account