(a) That there was some fluctuation of tradition is evident in the
case of Jehoiakim, with whose quiet end (2 Kings xxiv. 6 [see also
Lucian]; 2 Chron. xxxvi. 8 [Septuagint]) contrast the fate
foreshadowed in Jer. xxii. 18 seq., xxxvi. 30 (cf. Jos. _Ant._ x. 6, 2
seq.). The tradition of his captivity (2 Chron. xxxvi. 6; Dan. i. 2)
has apparently confused him with Jehoiachin, and the latter's reign is
so brief that some overlapping is conceivable. Moreover, the prophecy
in Jer. xxxiv. 5 that Zedekiah would die in peace is not borne out by
the history, nor does Josiah's fate agree with the promise in 2 Kings
xxii. 20. There is also an evident relation between the pairs:
Jehoahaz and Jehoiakim, Jehoiachin and Zedekiah (e.g. length of
reigns), and the difficulty felt in regard to the second and third is
obvious in the attempts of the Jewish historian Josephus to provide a
compromise. The contemporary prophecies ascribed to Jeremiah and
Ezekiel require careful examination in this connexion, partly as
regards their traditional background (especially the headings and
setting), and partly for their contents, the details of which
sometimes do not admit of a literal interpretation in accordance with
our present historical material (cf. Ezek. xix. 3-9, where the two
brothers carried off to Egypt and Babylon respectively would seem to
be Jehoahaz and his nephew Jehoiachin).
(b) Some fluctuation is obvious in the number, dates and extent of the
deportations. Jer. lii. 28-30 gives a total of 4600 persons, in
contrast to 2 Kings xxiv. 14, 16 (the numbers are not inclusive), and
reckons three deportations in the 7th (? 17th), 18th and 23rd years of
Nebuchadrezzar. Only the second is specifically said to be from
Jerusalem (the remaining are of Judaeans), and the last has been
plausibly connected with the murder of Gedaliah, an interval of five
years being assumed. For this twenty-third year Josephus (_Ant._ x. 9,
7) gives an invasion of Egypt and an attack upon Ammon, Moab and
Palestine (see NEBUCHADREZZAR).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account