The fourth section (chs. xlviii.-lx.) traces the history of the East
Goths from the same Hunnish invasion to the first overthrow of the
Gothic monarchy in Italy (376-539). In this fourth section are
inserted, somewhat out of their proper place, some valuable details as
to the _Gothi Minores_, "an immense people dwelling in the region of
Nicopolis, with their high priest and primate Vulfilas, who is said
also to have taught them letters." The book closes with the allusion
to Germanus and the panegyric on Justinian as the conqueror of the
Goths referred to above.
Jordanes refers in the _Getica_ to a number of authors besides
Cassiodorus; but he owes his knowledge of them to Cassiodorus. It is
perhaps only when he is using Orosius that we can hold Jordanes to
have borrowed directly. Otherwise, as Mommsen says, the _Getica is a
mera epitome, laxata ea et perversa, historiae Gothicae
Cassiodorianae_.
As to the style and literary character of Jordanes, every author who
has used him speaks in terms of severe censure. When he is left to
himself and not merely transcribing, he is sometimes scarcely
grammatical. There are awkward gaps in his narrative and statements
inconsistent with each other. He quotes, as if he were familiarly
acquainted with their writings, a number of Greek and Roman writers,
of whom it is almost certain that he had not read more than one or
two. At the same time he does not quote the chronicler Marcellinus,
from whom he has copied verbatim the history of the deposition of
Augustulus. All these faults make him a peculiarly unsatisfactory
authority where we cannot check his statements by those of other
authors. It may, however, be pleaded in extenuation that he is
professedly a transcriber, and, if his story be correct, a
transcriber in peculiarly unfavourable circumstances. He has also
himself suffered much from the inaccuracy of copyists. But nothing has
really been more unfortunate for the reputation of Jordanes as a
writer than the extreme preciousness of the information which he has
preserved to us. The Teutonic tribes whose dim origins he records have
in the course of centuries attained to world-wide dominion. The battle
in the Mauriac plains of which he is really the sole historian, is now
seen to have had important bearings on the destinies of the world. And
thus the hasty pamphlet of a half-educated Gothic monk has been forced
into prominence, almost into rivalry with the finished productions of
the great writers of classical antiquity. No wonder that it stands the
comparison badly; but with all its faults the _Getica_ of Jordanes
will probably ever retain its place side by side with the _De moribus
Germanorum_ of Tacitus as a chief source of information respecting the
history, institutions and modes of thought of our Teutonic
forefathers.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account