the study of logic and prepared the way for a more thorough
consideration of logical doctrines. The position assigned to logic by
Kant is not, in all probability, one which can be defended; indeed, it
is hard to see how Kant himself, in consistency with the critical
doctrine of knowledge, could have retained many of the older logical
theorems, but the precision with which the position was stated, and
the sharpness with which logic was marked off from cognate philosophic
disciplines, prepared the way for the more thoughtful treatment of the
whole question.
Formal logic thus yields to Kant the list of the general notions, pure
intellectual predicates, or categories, through which alone experience
is possible for a conscious subject. It has already been noted how
serious was the error involved in the description of these as notions,
without further attempt to clear up their precise significance. Kant,
indeed, was mainly influenced by his strong opposition to the
Leibnitzian rationalism, and therefore assigns the categories to
understanding, the logical faculty, without consideration of the
question,--which might have been suggested by the previous statements
of the _Dissertation_,--what relation these categories held to the
empirical notions formed by comparison, abstraction and generalization
when directed upon representations of objects. But when the categories
are described as notions, i.e. formed products of thought, there rises
of necessity the problem which had presented itself to Kant at every
stage of his precritical thinking,--with what right can we assume that
these notions apply to objects of experience? The answer which he
proceeds to give altogether explodes the definition of the categories
as formed products of thought, and enables us to see more clearly the
nature of the new conception of experience which lies in the
background of all the critical work.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account