The unity of the ego, which has been already noted as an element
entering into the synthesis of cognition, is a unity of a quite
distinct and peculiar kind. That the ego to which different parts of
experience are presented must be the same ego, if there is to be
cognition at all, is analytically evident; but the peculiarity is that
the ego must be conscious of its own unity and identity, and this
unity of self-consciousness is only possible in relation to difference
not contained in the ego but given to it. The unity of apperception,
then, as Kant calls it, is only possible in relation to synthetic
unity of experience itself, and the forms of this synthetic unity, the
categories, are, therefore, on the one hand, necessary as forms in
which self-consciousness is realized, and, on the other hand,
restricted in their application and validity to the data of given
sense, or the particular element of experience. Thus experience
presents itself as the organic combination of the particular of sense
with the individual unity of the ego through the universal forms of
the categories. Reference of representations to the unity of the
object, synthetic unity of apperception, and subsumption of data of
sense under the categories, are thus three sides or aspects of the one
fundamental fact.
In this deduction of the categories, as Kant calls it, there appears
for the first time an endeavour to connect together into one organic
whole the several elements entering into experience. It is evident,
however, that much was wanting before this essential task could be
regarded as complete. Kant has certainly brought together
self-consciousness, the system of the categories and data of sense. He
has shown that the conditions of self-consciousness are the conditions
of possible experience. But he has not shown, nor did he attempt to
show, how it was that the conditions of self-consciousness are the
very categories arrived at by consideration of the system of logical
judgments. He does endeavour to show, but with small success, how the
junction of category and data of sense is brought about, for according
to his scheme these stood, to a certain extent at least, apart from
and independent of one another. The failure to effect an organic
combination of the several elements was the natural consequence of the
false start which had been made.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account