English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised EditionBond, Francis
History
English Cathedrals Illustrated: Second and Revised Edition
Bond, Francis
Cathedrals -- England; Cathedrals -- Wales
Of the Anglo-Saxon cathedrals in wood or stone nothing remains. The
architectural history of the present cathedral commences with the
accession of the second Norman prelate, William of St. Carilef, or St.
Calais on the southern border of Maine, who was bishop from 1081 to 1095,
and is said to have laid the foundations of the Norman cathedral in 1093
on August 11th. The building operations of the Norman cathedral admit
of a threefold division: (1) The choir and choir aisles; the arcade and
triforium of the eastern aisles of both transepts; the crossing; the
first bay of the nave and the first arch of the nave-triforium; and the
whole of the outer walls of the nave up to the top of the aisle-arcade of
intersecting arches. All this is supposed to have been built by William
of St. Carilef between August 11th, 1093, and January 6th, 1096; _i.e._,
in two and a half years; which seems impossible. (2) In the interval
of three years between Carilef’s death and the appointment of Ralph
Flambard, the monks are said to have finished the transepts. (3) Between
1099 and his death in 1128, Ralph Flambard finished the nave. These three
divisions are architecturally correct; they are borne out by differences
of detail; and they follow the same order of building which was observed
elsewhere. But it does not follow that the exact dates given above, on
mediæval authority, are correct.
The most important matter is the date of the high vaults. From
architectural evidence it is pretty clear that the vaulting was executed
in the following order: (1) the vaults of the aisles of the choir and
transepts, said to be not later than 1099; (2) the high vault of the
choir, now destroyed, said to be not later than 1104; (3) the vaults of
the aisles of the nave, said to be not later than 1128; (4) the high
vaults of the transepts and nave, said to be not later than 1133. The
chronology of the high vaults is a very important question in the history
of mediæval architecture, especially as affecting the reputation of
English architects. If the above dates are correct, it was the Durham
architect, and not a Frenchman, who was the first to solve the great
problem of mediæval architecture: how to construct and keep up a ribbed
vault, oblong in plan, over a central aisle. With it goes the question
of priority in the use of flying-buttresses to take the thrust of a high
vault. If the dates given above are correct, Durham was a generation
ahead of the whole world in the construction of a high vault and in the
use of flying-buttresses.
[Illustration: WEST TOWERS.]
But the transverse arches of the vault of the nave are pointed; a feature
which occurs nowhere else in England at so early a date. Besides, it
seems impossible that if the Durham people had solved the problem of
problems of mediæval architecture—the construction of a high oblong
vault—nobody else should have copied it in England for more than fifty
years.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account