Erewhon Revisited Twenty Years Later, Both by the Original Discoverer of the Country and by His SonButler, Samuel
Philosophy
Erewhon Revisited Twenty Years Later, Both by the Original Discoverer of the Country and by His Son
Butler, Samuel
Satire; Utopian fiction; Utopias -- Fiction
“Panky must persuade himself of his own lies, before he is quite
comfortable about telling them to other people. Hanky keeps Hanky well
out of it; Panky must have a base of operations in Panky. Hanky will
lead him by the nose, bit by bit, for his is the master spirit. In
England Panky would be what we call an extreme ritualist.”
“Then the real battle will be between Hanky and Dr. Downie. Which will
carry the day?”
“For the present, probably Hanky. He is the more vigilant, and
energetic; in this case Sunchildism will have to go, and I am afraid your
whole Musical Bank system will be swept away along with it.”
“And why not?”
“Because, my dear boy, though false in the letter, if good counsels
prevail, it may be made true enough in spirit. If it were to go, its
place would be soon filled by men who would be as false in letter as the
others were, and much more false in spirit. You want a heart to check
your head, and a head to check your heart. As in our English body
politic there are two parties opposed to one another, neither of which
can thrive if the other is unduly weakened, so in our spiritual and
intellectual world two parties more or less antagonistic are equally
necessary. Those who are at the head of science provide us with the one
party; those whom we call our churchmen are the other. Both are corrupt,
but we can spare neither, for each checks as far as it can the
corruptions of the other.”
“Then you would have us uphold Sunchildism, knowing it to be untrue?”
“Do what you will, you will not get perfect truth. And if you can follow
the lead which I believe Dr. Downie will give you, that is to say, get
rid of cock-and-bull stories, idealise my unworthy self, and, as I said
last night, make me a peg on which to hang your own best
thoughts--Sunchildism will be as near truth as anything you are likely to
get. But if Hankyism triumphs, come what may you must get rid of it, for
he and his school will tamper with the one sure and everlasting word of
God revealed to us by human experience. He who plays fast and loose with
this is as one who would forge God’s signature to a cheque drawn on God’s
own bank.”
“Are we to foster the belief that it was indeed the Sunchild who
interrupted Hanky’s sermon?”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account