Essay on the Literature of the Mexican WarLawson, W. T. (William Thornton)
History
Essay on the Literature of the Mexican War
Lawson, W. T. (William Thornton)
Mexican War, 1846-1848 -- Bibliography
After commenting on Taylor’s mistakes at Palo Alto and criticizing
severely his movement upon Monterey, he denounces his generalship in
that battle and the armistice which followed. As to Buena Vista, he
evidently thinks that it was won in spite of Taylor, and he says that
the battle was saved once by the brilliant courage and hard fighting
of Davis’s Mississippi regiment, and again by the timely and splendid
execution of Bragg’s battery; that Davis suggested his own movement,
and that Bragg moved without orders in the direction of the plateau,
and both came in at the proper hour, and were both successful――giving
fresh proof of the “supremacy of fortune in war.”
His criticisms of Scott are intensely bitter, and he says that the
first great cause of American success in the operations around the
City of Mexico lay in the bravery and courage of the army, and not in
the ability and skill of the General-in-Chief, who (in our author’s
opinion) gave more attention to politics and his own personal position
than to the operations of the war.
Santa Anna is skillfully and ably portrayed, and appears as the most
remarkable figure on either side. Ripley charges that Scott was
successfully duped by the Mexican from the outset of his movement from
Puebla till the capture of the city.
With all its faults, this book of Ripley’s is the very best history
of the war with Mexico that has been written, and it will probably
always remain the standard military history of the war, as Kinglake’s
is of the Crimean contest, and Napier’s of the Peninsular War――the
two military histories of surpassing excellence. Its author, who is
still alive and in the perfection of his powers, ought to revise it
by the light of subsequent events, and leave it to his country as an
imperishable record of the most glorious war which the Union has ever
fought.
THE MEXICAN WAR: A History of its Origin, with a detailed
Account of its Victories, which terminated in the Surrender
of the Capital, with Official Despatches of the Generals. By
Edward D. Mansfield, a graduate of the United States Military
Academy. Illustrated with Maps and Engravings. New York. 1848.
12mo, 343 pages.
This author was born in Connecticut in 1801. His father afterwards
became the first Professor of Natural Philosophy at West Point, and
there the son graduated in 1819. Declining a commission in the Corps
of Engineers, he resumed his studies at Princeton and graduated there
in 1822. He then practiced law in Connecticut, whence he removed to
Cincinnati, and practiced law there till 1836, when he abandoned law
for literature.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account