I frankly confess that the supposed rational proofs--ontological,
cosmological, ethical, etc.--of the existence of God, prove to me
nothing; that all the reasons adduced to show that a God exists appear
to me to be based on sophistry and begging of the question. In this I
am with Kant. And in discussions of this kind, I feel that I am unable
to talk to cobblers in the terms of their craft.
Nobody has succeeded in convincing me rationally of the existence of
God, nor yet of His non-existence; the arguments of atheists appear to
me even more superficial and futile than those of their opponents. And
if I believe in God, or at least believe that I believe in Him, it is,
first of all, because I wish that God may exist, and then, because He
is revealed to me, through the channel of the heart, in the Gospel and
in Christ and in history. It is an affair of the heart.
Which means that I am not convinced of it as I am of the fact that two
and two make four.
If it were a question of something that did not touch my peace of
conscience or console me for having been born, perhaps I should pay
no heed to the problem; but as it involves my whole interior life and
the spring of all my actions, I cannot quiet myself by saying: I do
not know nor can I know. I do not know, that is certain; perhaps I can
never know. But I want to know. I want to, and that is enough.
And I shall spend my life wrestling with mystery, and even without
hope of penetrating it, for this wrestling is my sustenance and my
consolation. Yes, my consolation. I have accustomed myself to wrest
hope from despair itself. And let not fools in their superficiality
shriek: Paradox!
I cannot conceive of a man of culture without this preoccupation, and
in point of culture--and culture is not the same as civilization--I
can hope but little from those who live without interest in the
metaphysical aspect of the religious problem, and only study it in
its social or political aspects. I can hope but very little for the
enrichment of the spiritual treasury of mankind from those men or from
those peoples who, whether it be from intellectual inertia, or from
superficiality, or from scientificism, or from any other cause, are
unmoved by the great and eternal disquietudes of the heart. I can hope
nothing from those who say: “We must not think about these things!” I
can hope even less from those who believe in a heaven and a hell such
as those which we believed in when we were children; and still less can
I hope from those who affirm with a fool’s gravity: “All this is but
myth and fable; he who dies is buried and there’s an end of it.” I can
hope for something only from those who do not know, but who are not
resigned not to know; from those who fight unrestingly for the truth
and put their life in the fight itself rather than in the victory.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account