Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2) — John Shaqi
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
It is a difficult life that we enter upon, in entering upon a medical
career; but if our Christianity is worth anything, it must be ‘a
battle, not a dream.’ We must be members of the church militant if we
wish to enter the church triumphant. Life is a grand preparation for
the exercise of ever larger powers, and I heartily welcome you to this
winter’s course of study, hoping that it may be a little step forward,
but a sure one, towards that grand ideal which must be ever before us.
ERRONEOUS METHOD IN MEDICAL EDUCATION
_Addressed originally[1] to the Alumnæ Association of the Woman’s
Medical College of the New York Infirmary_
ERRONEOUS METHOD IN MEDICAL EDUCATION
Although it is many years since I have been able to assist in the
management of the Infirmary and School which I helped to found in 1853,
yet I watch its growth with steady sympathy, and rejoice in its success.
The last Report of the School, which has just reached me, contains
a very important item--viz., the effort of the Alumnæ Association
to ‘Equip a Physiological Laboratory and place it under the
superintendence of Professor W. Gilman Thompson,’ a New York
Vivisector. In relation to this effort, I desire to bring before you
some grave considerations which are the result of my long experience in
Medicine.
These considerations refer, _first_, to the kind of work that should be
carried on in a Physiological Laboratory, and, _second_, to the special
influence which women are called on to exercise in medicine.
A Physiological or Pathological Laboratory arranged for the
legitimate investigation of the material composition of the tissues
and secretions of the human body, is an interesting and important
department of medical study. The laboratory, however, is now commonly
used as a place for experimenting upon living animals as if they were
dead matter, or simple machines. This method of research is proving in
several ways extremely injurious to the progress of the Healing Art.
The practice of Vivisection and unlimited experimentations upon our
humbler fellow-creatures must be considered by us both under its
intellectual and its moral aspects. From both these points of view very
careful observation has led me to the conviction that this method of
investigation is a grave error.
Let me here state distinctly that I willingly acknowledge the good
intentions of all and the ability of some of the clever physiologists
of the present day, although their method of experimentation is
erroneous and the effects of that method injurious, being founded
on a fallacy. What I now say, however, is directed chiefly to the
instruction of medical students and to the practice of our young women
doctors.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account