Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
The exercise of our superior cunning in destroying an animal’s natural
means of self-defence, that we may (with convenience to ourselves)
watch changes that occur in its organs during the slow process of a
lingering death, is an exercise of curiosity which inevitably tends
to blunt the moral sense and injure that intelligent sympathy with
suffering, which is a fundamental quality in the good physician. The
practice of recklessly sacrificing animal life for the gratification,
either of curiosity, excitement, or cruelty, tends inevitably to create
a habit of mind which affects injuriously all our relations with
inferior or helpless classes of creatures. It tends to make us less
scrupulous in our treatment of the sick and helpless poor. It increases
that disposition to regard the poor as ‘clinical material,’ which
has become, alas! not without reason, a widespread reproach to many
of the young members of our most honourable and merciful profession.
The hardening effect of vivisection is distinctly recognised in the
Profession, although often excused under the abused term--‘scientific.’
Dr. Loye, who, with another physician, studied the process of
guillotining a malefactor at Troyes, thus writes: ‘Both of us believed
that our wide experience of bloody vivisection would have hardened us
sufficiently to go through the spectacle without very great emotion.’
It is our duty and privilege, as women entering into the medical
profession, to strengthen its humane aspirations--to discourage its
dangerous tendencies. We must not be misled by clever or brilliant
materialists who take the narrow view that physical life can be
profitably studied without reverencing the spiritual force on which
it depends. A physiological and pathological laboratory, legitimately
conducted for the investigation of healthy and diseased human
secretions, in connection with clinical observation, may be made a
valuable aid to medical advancement, and I would always encourage the
organization of such a laboratory. But to use it for cutting up animals
dying under anæsthetics is stupidity, and to convert it into a torture
chamber of the lower animals, is an intellectual error and a moral
crime.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account