Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
This fact, confirmed in the mind of the bacteriologist by the
fallacious system of diseasing animals as ‘témoins’ or ‘controls,’ has
given rise to the dangerous theory that all contagious diseases may
be forestalled in their most deadly form by the inoculation of human
beings with diluted virus produced by those diseases. This dangerous
belief has been widely fostered by the unfortunate educational
influence of the law of compulsory vaccination. But it must be observed
that vaccination, unlike inoculation, does not introduce any products
of the special disease--small-pox--into the system. The vaccine disease
in the cow is not small-pox, nor can it ever be made to produce
small-pox. The preservative power which is claimed for it, therefore,
has not the dangers which are attached to inoculation, but neither
can it claim the occasional immunity which may attend that dangerous
practice of introducing small-pox virus into the blood. Pure air,
cleanliness, and decent house-room secured to all our people, form the
true prophylaxis of small-pox.
_Exaggeration of Bacteriology._--We observe how neglect of the Law of
Unity is misleading the intellect in relation to bacteriology. This
subject, useful if pursued without cruelty and in subordination to
higher facts, has become a mischievous exaggeration[7] both as to what
it signifies and as to what it may lead to.
The majority of our active and intelligent medical investigators are
now intensely engaged in the search for a microbe as the primary
_cause_ of every disease known to humanity. Cancer, leprosy, fevers,
hydrophobia, diphtheria, tetanus, insanity, etc., are being largely
studied by this imperfect method, in hope of finding a characteristic
microbe which can be pronounced the essential cause of the disease.
The great mental energy of biological investigators is diverted from
sanitary investigation to the search for fresh bacilli. Admirable
perseverance, acute ingenuity, unwearied energy are devoted to this
search.
Advantage has been taken of the helplessness of the lower animals
to carry on a system of experimentation upon them, the extent and
ruthlessness of which has never before been attempted. Disease
is studiously propagated. Myriads of healthy living creatures
are filled with loathsome disease in order to furnish ‘material’
for experimentation. So many kilos of dog or rabbit (used for
injecting disease, or noted as more or less slowly resisting the
death thus gradually inflicted) is a common expression now used
in experimentation, and supposed to give ‘scientific accuracy’ to
experiments. It is a pitiful intellectual fallacy of short-sighted
materialism that supposes it possible to obtain ‘scientific accuracy’
by regarding so many kilos of living dog as if they could be
experimented on as so many kilos of dead matter, or as if they were
the materials of a steam-engine, which can be taken apart, examined,
cleaned, tested, and put together again in complete working order.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account