Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2) — John Shaqi
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)Blackwell, Elizabeth
Science
Essays in medical sociology, Volume 2 (of 2)
Blackwell, Elizabeth
Prostitution; Sexual ethics; Social medicine
The new bacteriological theory directly contradicts this important
law of sanitary experience, and in opposition to it authoritatively
announces that contagious or infectious disease can never be produced
without the antecedent microbe. It was in defence of this untenable
theory that the distinguished professor claimed the ‘right of science
to dictate.’
The great mistake, therefore, made by the Hygienic Congress was the
neglect of mind as an indispensable and prominent factor in Health, and
the exaltation of bacteriology, with the theories based upon it, into
the chief point of interest and importance.
The modern exaggeration of bacteriology, with its theory of
inoculation, must be steadily opposed by all who realize the power and
growing influence of spiritual life. The injurious results of this
exaggeration may be summarized as follows:
_The Practical Dangers arising from erroneous Scientific Method._--1.
It diverts invaluable intellectual activity into methods of
comparatively futile investigation. These investigations lead very
widely to the exercise of fraud and cruelty upon the lower animals,
and tend to reckless experiment on the poor. They waste much time and
spread the contagion of intellectual error amongst the students of all
our medical schools, where the false practices of experimentation are
increasingly carried on. They also pervert the moral sense of the great
army of assistants, caretakers, porters, nurses, and others connected
with our medical institutions, who become aware of the cruel practices
which so largely accompany this method of research.
2. This perversion of medical activity misleads our Parliamentary
representatives, who are bewildered by pseudo-science authoritatively
announcing itself as Truth, and permits a rapid increase of officialism
to crush opposition and force the dicta of superficial ‘science’ upon
the protesting conscience of intelligent people. It also misleads the
community by fallacious articles in popular magazines, in which facts,
theories, statistics, and assertions, often incorrect, are given with
an imposing air of science, in relation to which the ordinary reader is
quite unable to discriminate the true from the false.
3. The diversion of medical activity from the true path of Preventive
Medicine not only hinders the progress of sanitation, but is producing
an increasing revolt of common-sense and popular feeling against what
are erroneously supposed to be the necessary methods of medicine and
the practice of dispensary and hospital. This growing feeling in the
community increases the dread with which the poor generally regard
the hospital, and it also seriously diminishes the pecuniary support
which the well-to-do would otherwise gladly extend to their sick and
suffering fellow-creatures.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account