Essays In Pastoral MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Religion
Essays In Pastoral Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
First aid in illness and injury; Medicine
1. The term _object_ has various meanings, but here it means the deed
performed in the action, the thing which the will chooses. That deed
by its very nature may be good, or it may be bad, or it may be
indifferent morally. In themselves to help the afflicted is a good
action, to blaspheme is a bad action, to walk is an indifferent
action. Some bad actions are absolutely bad, they never can become
good or indifferent (blasphemy or adultery, for example); others, as
stealing, are evil because of a lack of right in the agent: these
may become good by acquiring the missing right. Others are evil
because of the danger necessarily connected with their
performance,--the danger of sin connected with them, or the
unnecessary peril to life. An action to have the moral quality must
be voluntary, deliberate; and mere repugnance in doing an act does
not in itself make the act involuntary.
2. Circumstances sometimes, though not always, can add a {13} new
element of good or evil to an action. The circumstances of an action
are the agent, the object, the place in which the action is done,
the means used, the end in view, the method observed in using the
means, the time in which the deed is done. If a judge in his
official position tells a sheriff to hang a criminal, and a private
citizen gives the same command, the actions are very different
morally because of the circumstances of the agent giving the
command. The object--it changes the morality of the deed if a man
steals a cent or a thousand dollars. The place--what might be merely
a filthy action in a house might be a sacrilege in a church. The
means--to support a family by labour or by thievery. The end in
view--to give alms in obedience to divine command or to give them
to buy votes. The method observed in using means--kindly, say, or
cruelly. The time--to do manual labour on Sunday or on Monday. Some
circumstances aggravate the evil in a deed, some extenuate it.
Others may so colour a deed that they specify the deed, make the
action some special virtue or vice. The circumstance that a murderer
is the son of the man he kills specifies the deed as parricide.
The end also determines the morality of an action (see St Thomas,
_Sum. Theol_. I. 2., q. xviii., a. 4 and 7). Since the end is the
first thing in the intention of the agent, he passes from the object
wished for in the end to choosing the means for obtaining it. Without
the end the means can not exist as such. There are occasions when an
end is only a circumstance: for example, if it is a concomitant end.
When an end is a, _finis extrinsecus operantis_, when it is in keeping
with right reason or discordant thereto, it may become a determinant
of morality.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account