Essays In Pastoral MedicineWalsh, James J. (James Joseph)
Religion
Essays In Pastoral Medicine
Walsh, James J. (James Joseph)
First aid in illness and injury; Medicine
Now, since Schrenck found 610 ectopic gestations reported in five
years, this indicates that the average number of cases of ectopic
gestation which occur in the civilised world is at the least 122 a
year, for many more (twice as many, at the lowest {34} estimate) are
not diagnosed or not reported when diagnosed. In the 80 years, then,
between 1809 and 1896 there were at the least 9760 cases of ectopic
gestation in the civilised world; in the uncivilised countries there
were certainly as many more with not a child saved, or even brought
out of the pelvic cavity. To be sure, by rejecting perhaps a third of
the cases through bad diagnoses and neglect of reports, there were
20,000 cases; and in all these hardly 20 children baptised--one in a
thousand.
Modern surgical methods and improved diagnosis will do little to
better the condition, from the nature of the disease. Between 1893 and
1896 there were 21 cases of operation for the delivery of viable
foetuses reported, and this list is approximately correct, because the
surgeons that operate on such material are men that as a rule report
their work even when it is to their discredit. In these 21 cases, 6
mothers, 28 per centum died, 72 per centum recovered. Even if modern
surgery should save all the mothers who had escaped until the foetus
was viable, and should bring all the children to baptism, there would
not be more than about 7 such cases in the world annually. Increased
skill in diagnosis would raise the number of children brought to
baptism, but it would more than proportionately raise the whole number
of ectopic gestations discovered. If 10 foetuses were brought from the
pelvic cavity alive in the 130 cases of ectopic gestation of the year,
the chances for an extrauterine foetus to only reach baptism at a
viable age (not to live after baptism) are only 7 in 100 at a most
liberal estimate. Statistics are unreliable, of course, but I am
giving odds of two to one. The foetus has a much better chance for
baptism if the coeliotomy is done as early in the pregnancy as
possible, but it has a negligible chance of life in any case. Since
the creation of man there have been less than 15 extrauterine children
saved, and of these 15 four were less than a year old when reported,
and three under five years of age: the oldest was fifteen years of
age, and all were weaklings.
The practical rule, then, is that the ectopic foetus will die anyhow,
and operation only _indirectly_ (mark the word) accelerates the
inevitable death of a materially unjust aggressor, {35} while it gives
the mother the best chance for her life, which is in very grave peril.
Case III. The surgeon before operation diagnoses with the help of
consultors extrauterine pregnancy, but he or they can not tell whether
the foetus is alive or not. What should he do?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account