Although Count Tolstoi divided his life into four distinct periods,
and although critics have often insisted on the great difference
between his earlier and his later work, these differences fade away on
a close scrutiny of the man's whole production, from "Childhood" to
"Resurrection."
"Souls alter not, and mine must still advance," said Browning. This is
particularly true of Tolstoi. He progressed, but did not change; and
he progressed along the path already clearly marked in his first
books. The author of "Sevastopol" and "The Cossacks" was the same man
mentally and spiritually who wrote "Anna Karenina," "Ivan Ilyich,"
"The Kreuzer Sonata," and "Resurrection." Indeed, few great authors
have steered so straight a course as he. No such change took place in
him as occurred with Bjornson. The teaching of the later books is more
evident, the didactic purpose is more obvious, but that is something
that happens to almost all writers as they descend into the vale of
years. The seed planted in the early novels simply came to a perfectly
natural and logical fruition.
Not only do the early novels indicate the direction that Tolstoi's
whole life was bound to assume, but his diary and letters show the
same thing. The extracts from these that I have given above are
substantial proof of this--he saw the truth just as clearly in 1855 as
he saw it in 1885, or in 1905. The difference between the early and
later Tolstoi is not, then, a difference in mental viewpoint, it is a
difference in conduct and action.* The eternal moral law of
self-sacrifice was revealed to him in letters of fire when he wrote
"The Cossacks" and "Sevastopol;" everything that he wrote after was a
mere amplification and additional emphasis. But he was young then; and
although he saw the light, he preferred the darkness. He knew then,
just as clearly as he knew later, that the life in accordance with New
Testament teaching was a better life than that spent in following his
animal instincts; but his knowledge did not save him.
*For a very unfavourable view of Tolstoi's later conduct, the
"Tolstoi legend," see Merezhkovski, Tolstoi as Man and Artist.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account