Essays, or discourses, vol. 4 (of 4) : $b Selected from the works of Feyjoo, and translated from the SpanishFeijoo, Benito Jerónimo
Philosophy
Essays, or discourses, vol. 4 (of 4) : $b Selected from the works of Feyjoo, and translated from the Spanish
Feijoo, Benito Jerónimo
Spanish essays -- Translations into English
LXI. It seems then, that the innocent are exposed to equal danger from
the torture with the guilty. A terrible inconvenience this, but the worst
part of it is, that the danger is not equal, but greater on the side of
innocence. I may be told that I am advancing a new paradox, and I confess
that I am, but if I am not greatly mistaken, I shall make it appear,
that I have been advancing nothing that is not strictly true. It is a
known fact, that those who are daring enough to commit great crimes, are
much more hardened, robust, and ferocious people, than those who lead a
quiet and regular life. It should follow then from these premises, that
they are better calculated to endure the rigours of a torture, than the
tranquil and inoffensive part of mankind; and it will also follow from
thence, that these last will be more likely to confess themselves guilty
of a crime they are falsely accused of, than the others will be, to
confess one they have really committed. This is a remark made by father
Lacroix, and the following are his words: _sequitur per torturas sæpè
everti justitiam, quia innocentes, qui sæpè sunt impatientes dolorum,
coguntur se fateri nocentes; e contra nocentes, qui plerumque sunt
ferociores, tolerata tortura se probant innocentes._
LXII. On the contrary, those of quiet and peaceable dispositions,
are generally people of more delicate feelings than the others, and
especially, if their mode of living has corresponded with the native
excellence of their tempers. From whence it should follow, that the
probable result of putting one of these to the torture, would be, that
he would sooner confess himself guilty of a crime he never committed,
than one of the others, would own himself guilty of one he had actually
perpetrated.
LXIII. I consider the sentiment of Plato to be a true one, who says,
that great vices, no less than great virtues, require great powers and
fortitude to exercise them. The serenity with which Geronimus Olgiatus,
Balthasar Gerardus, and Francis Ravillac, the first for the assassination
of Galeazus Maria duke of Milan, the second for that of William prince
of Orange, and the third for that of Henry the Fourth of France, fully
demonstrate, that those who dare attempt great and dangerous things, are
capable of enduring great torments.
LXIV. I shall conclude this subject, with the striking, and most
efficacious testimony of Father Frederic Spe, which throws all the
light upon this matter that can be wished for, or desired. This learned
German Jesuit, when he is treating of the little dependance there is
to be placed on the confessions of people accused of witchcraft, which
confessions have been extorted from them by the rack; quotes, in support
of what he advances, the testimony of the Baron de Leibnitz, and Vincent
Placcius, whom he supposes to be the author of the anonymous Treatise,
intituled, _Cautio criminalis in processu contra sagas_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account