Essays, or discourses, vol. 4 (of 4) : $b Selected from the works of Feyjoo, and translated from the SpanishFeijoo, Benito Jerónimo
Philosophy
Essays, or discourses, vol. 4 (of 4) : $b Selected from the works of Feyjoo, and translated from the Spanish
Feijoo, Benito Jerónimo
Spanish essays -- Translations into English
XVIII. It is certain there are some truths, that maugre the clearness and
confidence with which the understanding assents to them, are not exempt
from being exposed to difficult objections; or to speak more properly,
there is no truth whatever, be it ever so firmly established, against
which, some sophistical objection may not be raised. It would therefore
not be right upon all occasions, to give up a maxim, whose truth we
clearly perceive and are convinced of, only because we can’t reply to
every argument that may be urged against it. There are truths of such
a nature, that although they would strike, and be clear to any man of
ordinary understanding, still, the giving an answer to every objection
that could be raised against them, might possibly be found a difficult
task to a person of very subtil ingenuity. And notwithstanding we should
not be able to hit upon an argument, that would confront or silence those
which are used by the sceptics, to persuade us to doubt whether we are
sleeping or waking, we should not abandon ourselves to such a doubt, but
support ourselves in a firm confidence, that we are not mistaken with
respect to the state we are in. And in truth, the arguments used to make
us doubt of it, are not of such a nature, as that a clear, solid, and
unembarrassed answer may not be given to them.
XIX. And in order to do this, I shall begin with supposing, that evidence
in this case may be of two sorts, mediate, and immediate. An evident
proposition, supported by immediate evidence, is, when without the
assistance of any kind of proof, it presents itself so clearly to our
understandings, that the mind is constrained by invincible necessity to
assent to it. An evident proposition supported by mediate evidence, is,
when of itself, it is not represented to our understandings with all
this clearness, but is necessarily inferred from some other self-evident
proposition.
XX. I will suppose, secondly, that immediate evidence should be divided,
into metaphysical and experimental. The first is governed by universal
principles, which of themselves persuade or convince the understanding;
such as these, the whole is greater than a part; two contradictory
propositions can’t be both true at one and the same time. Experimental
evidence is derived from certain singular truths, which strike every
individual with infallible conviction; such as these, that I at present
have such or such a desire, or that I think of such or such a thing, that
I suffer some pain, or that I am affected with some particular sensation;
for example, joy, sadness, or anger.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account