"What constitutes the difficulty for a man laboring under an
unwise passion acting as if the passion were unwise?... The
difficulty is mental; it is that of getting the idea of the wise
action to stay before our mind at all. When any strong emotional
state whatever is upon us the tendency is for no images but such
as are congruous with it to come up. If others by chance offer
themselves, they are instantly smothered and crowded out.... By a
sort of self-preserving instinct which our passion has, it feels
that these chill objects [the thoughts of what is disagreeable to
the passion] if they once but gain a lodgment, will work and work
until they have frozen the very vital spark from out of all our
mood.... Passion's cue accordingly is always and everywhere to
prevent their still small voice from being heard at all."
This quotation refers to a strong passion. It is important to note _that
every interest, every emotion, of whatever nature or strength, works in
precisely the same way_. Upon this hangs the entertaining of memories
and ideas about things. Hence interest is the central factor in the
development of any concrete intention, both as to what it is and as to
what it is not--that is, what the aim would have been if the emotional
attitude had been different. Given a certain emotional attitude, and the
consequences which are pertinent to it are thought of, while other and
equally probable consequences are ignored. A man of a truly kindly
disposition is sensitive to, aware of, probable results on other
people's welfare; a cautious person sees consequences with reference to
his own standing; an avaricious man feels results in terms of the
probable increase or decrease of his possessions; and so on. The
intimate relation of interest and attention forms the inseparable tie of
intention, _what_ one will, to motive, _why_ he so wills. When Bentham
says that "Motives are the causes of intentions," he states the fact,
and also reveals motive as the proper final object of moral judgment.
§ 3. CONDUCT AND CHARACTER
The discussion enables us to place conduct and character in relation to
each other. Mill, after the passage already quoted (see above, p. 248),
to the effect that motive makes no difference to the morality of the
act, says it "makes a great difference in our moral estimation of the
_agent_, especially if it indicates a good or a bad habitual
_disposition_--a bent of character from which useful, or from which
hurtful, actions are likely to arise." To like effect Bentham:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account