Europe and the Faith: "Sine auctoritate nulla vita"Belloc, Hilaire
History
Europe and the Faith: "Sine auctoritate nulla vita"
Belloc, Hilaire
Catholic Church; Europe -- History
Here let us turn the light of common sense on to these most imperfect,
confused and few facts which Gildas gives us. What sort of thing would
a middle-aged man, writing in the decline of letters and with nothing
but poor and demonstrably distorted verbal records to go by, set down
with regard to a piece of warfare, if (a) that man were a monk and a
man of peace, (b) his object were obviously not history, but a sermon
on morals, and (c) the fighting was between the Catholic Faith, which
was all in all to the men of his time, and Pagans? Obviously he would
make all he could of the old and terrified legends of the time long
before his birth, he would get more precise as his birth approached
(though always gloomy and exaggerating the evil), and he would begin to
tell us precise facts with regard to the time he could himself
remember. Well, all we get from St. Gildas is the predatory incursions
of pagan savages from Scotland and Ireland, long, long before he was
born; a small number of auxiliaries called in to help the Roman
Provincials against these; the permanent settlement of these
auxiliaries in some quarter or other of the island (we know from other
evidence that it was the east and southeast coast); and (d) what is of
capital importance because it is really contemporary, _the settling
down of the whole matter, apparently during Gildas’ own lifetime in the
sixth century_—from say 500 A.D. or earlier to say 545 or later.
I have devoted so much space to this one writer, whose record would
hardly count in a time where any sufficient historical document
existed, because his book is _absolutely the only one contemporary
piece of evidence we have upon the pirate, or Saxon, raiding of
Britain_. [Footnote: The single sentence in Prosper is
insignificant—and what is more, demonstrably false as it stands.] There
are interesting fragments about it in the various documents known (to
us) collectively today as “The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle”—but these
documents were compiled many hundreds of years afterwards and had
nothing better to go on than St. Gildas himself and possibly a few
vague legends.
Now we happen to have in this connection a document which, though not
contemporary must be considered as evidence of a kind. It is sober and
full, written by one of the really great men of Catholic and European
civilization, written in a spirit of wide judgment and written by a
founder of history, the Venerable Bede.
True, the Venerable Bede’s _Ecclesiastical History_ was not produced
until _three hundred years after_ the first raids of these predatory
bands, not until nearly two hundred years after St. Gildas, and not
until one hundred and forty years after reading and writing and the
full tide of Roman civilization had come back to Eastern Britain with
St. Augustine: but certain fundamental statements of his are evidence.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account