But it is in aristocratic coddling that the effects of our educational
attitude gleam out to the least observant understanding. This is
the coddling of the preparatory schools and the colleges, and it is
more serious for it is a defect that cannot be explained away by
the hundred difficulties that beset good teaching in a public-school
system, nation-wide, and conducted for the young of every race in the
American menagerie. The teaching in the best American preparatory
schools and colleges is as careful and as conscientious as any in
the world. That one gladly asserts. Indeed, an American boy in a
good boarding-school is handled like a rare microbe in a research
laboratory. He is ticketed; every instant of his time is planned and
scrutinized; he is dieted with brain food, predigested, and weighed
before application. I sometimes wonder if a moron could not be made
into an Abraham Lincoln by such a system--if the system were sound.
It is not sound. The boys and girls, especially the boys, are coddled
for entrance examinations, coddled through freshman year, coddled
oftentimes for graduation. And they too frequently go out into the
world fireproof against anything but intellectual coddling. Such
men and women can read only writing especially prepared for brains
that will take only selected ideas, simply put. They can think only
on simple lines, not too far extended. They can live happily only
in a life where ideas never exceed the college sixty per cent of
complexity, and where no intellectual or esthetic experience lies too
far outside the range of their curriculum. A world where one reads the
news and skips the editorials; goes to musical comedies, but omits
the plays; looks at illustrated magazines, but seldom at books; talks
business, sports, and politics, but never economics, social welfare,
and statesmanship--that is the world for which we coddle the best of
our youth. Many indeed escape the evil effects by their own innate
originality; more bear the marks to the grave.
The process is simple, and one can see it in the English public
schools (where it is being attacked vivaciously) quite as commonly as
here. You take your boy out of his family and his world. You isolate
him except for companionship with other nursery transplantings and
teachers themselves isolated. And then you feed him, nay, you cram
him, with good traditional education, filling up the odd hours with
the excellent, but negative, passion of sport. Then you subject him to
a special cramming and send him to college, where sometimes he breaks
through the net of convention woven about him, and sees the real world
as it should appear to the student before he becomes part of it; but
more frequently wraps himself deep and more deeply in conventional
opinion, conventional practice, until, the limbs of his intellect bound
tightly, he stumbles into the outer world.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account