Fighting Without a War: An Account of Military Intervention in North Russia — John Shaqi
Fighting Without a War: An Account of Military Intervention in North RussiaAlbertson, Ralph
History
Fighting Without a War: An Account of Military Intervention in North Russia
Albertson, Ralph
World War, 1914-1918 -- Soviet Union
The first great step in the process of making Bolsheviki was the
conscription of men for the army. This was not done until ample
opportunity had been given everybody to enlist voluntarily, but not
everybody volunteered. The Russian point of view and ours were quite
different in this matter. We had undertaken to fight the Bolsheviki for
him and he was glad to have us do it. Our men and officers, on the
other hand, declared it was preposterous to suppose they were going to
do this fighting while the "lazy Russians stayed at home." So
conscription went into force. At first a small class of young men, then
a larger class, and finally practically every able-bodied man from
seventeen to fifty. Here was another story. Here was war, real war,
again. The new thing called Military Intervention or Allied Assistance
or anything else had proved to be the old thing that Russia knew so
well. And the peasant of North Russia did not want it. As early as
January some of these conscripted companies at Shenkursk went over
bodily to the Bolsheviki.
The suppression of all expressions of interest in Russia’s "new-found
freedom" was a stupid blunder. There were no public meetings, no open
discussion of political questions, no real freedom of the press. The
Russian soldiers were even afraid to sing the "Marseillaise," and
confined themselves to the innocuous if beautiful folksongs, leaving all
of the many excellent freedom songs of the revolution to the exclusive
use of the Bolsheviki. The British never discovered that the Russian
loves these freedom songs, because they took counsel solely of the
reactionary monarchist element they had placed in power.
I have known a single strain of one of these freedom songs to throw a
roomful of people into panic with fear that it meant a fresh revolt. And
I have seen a crowd of Russian soldiers respond with keen pleasure when
their officer, a friend of mine with whom I had talked the matter over,
told them to go ahead and sing the so-called Bolshevist songs. This was
toward the end of the chapter of Military Intervention.
The suspension of all kinds of democratic and political experiment and
experience by the Military Intervention was a matter of grave
consequence. After a year of Military Intervention a member of a
Zemstvo Upravda said to me, "We have made no progress in government. We
have lost ground. It could not have been worse under the Bolsheviki."
The people under Military Intervention felt that they were robbed of the
freedom they had waited for so long and enjoyed such a little time. The
belief that the Bolsheviki would have robbed them equally or worse
comforted them for a time, but this comfort wore away as time stretched
on and Military Intervention made constantly increasing demands upon
them.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account