Forerunners and rivals of Christianity : $b being studies in religious history from 330 B.C. to 330 A.D., Vol. 2 (of 2)Legge, Francis
Religion
Forerunners and rivals of Christianity : $b being studies in religious history from 330 B.C. to 330 A.D., Vol. 2 (of 2)
Legge, Francis
Christianity and other religions; Religions
Tertullian’s talk (_adv. Marcion._ Bk I. c. 1) about its barbarism and
the natives living in waggons is mere rhetoric. He probably knew
nothing about the place.
Footnote 691:
_Stoicae studiosus._ Tertullian, _de Praescript._ c. XXX.
Footnote 692:
_Id._ _adv. Marc._ Bk IV. c. 4; and _de Praescript._ c. XXX., where
the money is said to have been 200 sestertia or nearly £1800.
Footnote 693:
Tertullian, _adv. Marc._ Bk I. c. 2. Cf. Pseudo Tertullianus, _adv.
omn._ _Haer._ c. XVI.
Footnote 694:
Neander, _Ch. Hist._ II. p. 150; cf. Tertullian, _de Praescript._ c.
XLI.
Footnote 695:
_Ibid. op. cit._ c. XXX. Salmon (_Dict. Christian Biog._ _s.v._
Marcion) wishes to transfer this story to Cerdo.
Footnote 696:
Neander, _Church Hist._ II. p. 139, disbelieves it.
Footnote 697:
Justin Martyr, _First Apol._ cc. XXVI., LVIII. He writes as Marcion’s
contemporary. Cf. Clem. Alex. _Strom._ Bk III. c. 3.
Footnote 698:
Epiphanius, _Haer._ XLII. p. 553, Oehler.
Footnote 699:
Tertullian, _adv. Marc._ Bk IV. c. 5.
Footnote 700:
Eusebius, _Hist. Eccl._ Bk IV. c. 14.
Footnote 701:
The council was held 692 A.D. See Salmon in _Dict. Christian Biog._
_s.v._ Marcion.
Footnote 702:
Tertullian, _adv. Marc._ Bk I. c. 27.
Footnote 703:
The story that he seduced a virgin is now generally held to mean
merely that he corrupted the unsullied faith of the Church. Cf.
Hegesippus in Eusebius, _Hist. Eccl._ Bk V. c. 22. So Salmon, _art.
cit._ _supra_. As Neander points out (_Ch. Hist._ II. p. 136 note),
Tertullian, had he known the story, would certainly have published it.
Yet he contrasts Marcion’s chastity with the real or supposed
incontinence of his follower, Apelles (_de Praescript._ c. XXX.).
Footnote 704:
Irenaeus, Bk I. c. 25, p. 219, Harvey.
Footnote 705:
Hippolytus, _op. cit._ Bk VII. c. 3, p. 370, Cruice.
Footnote 706:
So Salmon, _art. cit._, Renan, and others. This view, however, cannot
apply to Justin Martyr who was, as we have seen, his contemporary. See
n. 5. p. 205 _supra_.
Footnote 707:
See Salmon (_Dict. Christian Biog._ _s.v._ Marcion) for authorities.
Footnote 708:
See Harnack’s article on _Marcion_ in _Encyc. Brit._ (11th ed.).
Footnote 709:
Tertullian, _adv. Marc._ Bk IV. c. 2. Marcion apparently knew nothing
of St John’s Gospel, which may not have become public till after his
death. Had he done so, as Renan says (_L’Égl. Chrétienne_, p. 71), he
would probably have preferred it to any other, because of its markedly
anti-Jewish tendency.
Footnote 710:
According to him, Jesus was not born of woman. Cf. Hippolytus, _op.
cit._ Bk VII. c. 31, pp. 383-384, Cruice.
Footnote 711:
The whole controversy is well summed up in Matter, _Hist. du Gnost._
t. II. pp. 238-242.
Footnote 712:
See Matter, _op. cit._ t. II. pp. 246-260, where Marcion’s emendations
are given chapter by chapter and their sources cited.
Footnote 713:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account