Forgers and ForgeriesConstable, W. G. (William George)
History
Forgers and Forgeries
Constable, W. G. (William George)
Art -- Forgeries
[Illustration: ABOVE: A forgery of Vermeer by Van Meegeren,
purporting to be an early work of the artist, purchased as an
original, compared with (BELOW) the earliest known painting signed
by Vermeer.]
[Illustration: (genuine example)]
More common than straight copies of particular objects, however, are
imitations of the style of some period or master. This avoids the risk
of comparison with a more or less identical original, and helps in
passing off the forgery as an unknown example of the style it imitates.
It was on this basis that Bastianini, Rouchomovski, and Dossena worked,
as did the German painter Roerich in his imitations of Cranach and other
early German masters. Usually such imitations of a style do not embody a
new conception or an original idea; for the most part they consist of
borrowings from original works, pieced together to make a more or less
consistent whole. Often, these borrowings are secondhand, being taken
from photographs, engravings, or reproductions in books. A specific case
was the use of Weisser’s _Bilderatlas zur Weltgeschichte_ (1882) by
Rouchomovski for the reliefs on the tiara of Saitapharnes. The use of
such models is, however, the Achilles’ heel of the forger. Once their
source is tracked down, detection of the imposture is almost certain.
[Illustration: A forgery of fourteenth-century Italian wood
sculpture by Dossena.]
[Illustration: An X-ray revealed modern nails in the interior.]
That, perhaps, is why forgers have on occasion virtually abandoned the
use of models, either wholly or in part, and produced objects different
from anything that is known, but which could fit into some particular
historical or cultural background. Here, they are exploiting not only
ignorant enthusiasm but the desire among the learned to extend knowledge
of little-known epochs of human history, or to find material that will
justify theories about them. Comparatively crude examples are the
so-called Baphomets, stone figures said to have been worshipped by the
Knights Templar; and the “medieval” pilgrim’s badges made in
nineteenth-century London by William Smith and Charles Eaton, now widely
known as “Billies and Charlies.” The appeal of the unknown was more
skillfully utilized by Rouchomovski and Van Meegeren. In the tiara of
Saitapharnes, existing models had been used, through reproductions, for
the reliefs and inscriptions; but as a whole, the tiara was something of
a kind unknown, yet eagerly sought for, and so was more readily accepted
when it came into the market. Similarly, unknown early works of Vermeer
had long been a matter of speculation among art historians, and in
certain quarters a hypothetical character for them had been built up; so
that when _The Disciples at Emmaus_ appeared and more or less fitted the
bill, it was all the more easy to believe in it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account