It is hardly necessary to pursue this particular subject further, but
before leaving it, attention may be drawn for a moment to the curious
conclusion that the ice-sheets were self-destructive. One is left to
guess at what particular stage the sinking process began, but if the
earth's crust were as readily deformed as the extreme views I have
been examining would compel one to imply, then depression must have
commenced almost immediately with the accumulation of snow and ice. The
several ice-sheets must soon have attained their maximum thickness,
and their disappearance must have been correspondingly rapid. And
yet all the evidence goes to show that a glacial epoch endured for
a comparatively long time--for a time sufficient to account for a
prodigious amount of rock-erosion, and for the accumulation of vast
sheets of glacial débris and fluvio-glacial detritus.[BY]
[BY] It must not be inferred from the above remarks that I deny the
possibility of deformation of the crust having been induced by the
old ice-sheets. The geological evidence is certainly suggestive of
such having been the case. But I much doubt whether the sinking of the
surface was brought about by the mere weight of the ice pressing the
crust down into a subjacent liquid layer. Dr. Drygalski's explanation
would better account for the geological phenomena, but, according to
Rev. Osmond Fisher, it cannot be maintained.
If it be difficult to understand how the "earth-movement hypothesis"
can account for the origin of one glacial epoch, the difficulty is
not lessened when we remember that there are two or more such epochs
to account for. And until the advocates of that hypothesis can
furnish us with some reliable evidence, they can hardly expect us to
believe in their mysterious upheavals and depressions of northern
and temperate regions, and in the no less wonderfully rhythmic
movements of the Isthmus of Panama. In fine, the views which I have
been controverting seem to me to be untenable, inasmuch as they are
founded on mere assumptions, and do not even give a reasonable and
intelligible explanation of the phenomena of glaciated regions, while
they practically ignore or leave unsolved the problem of interglacial
conditions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account