Fragments of Science: A Series of Detached Essays, Addresses, and Reviews. V. 1-2Tyndall, John
Science
Fragments of Science: A Series of Detached Essays, Addresses, and Reviews. V. 1-2
Tyndall, John
Chemistry; Physics; Science
But this is not all. Besides these universally admitted cases, there
is the broad theory, now broached and daily growing in strength and
clearness--daily, indeed, gaining more and more of assent from the
most successful workers and profound thinkers of the medical
profession itself--the theory, namely, that contagious disease,
generally, is of this parasitic character. Had I any cause to regret
having introduced this theory to your notice more than a year ago,
that regret should now be expressed. I would certainly renounce in
your presence whatever leaning towards the germ theory my words might
then have betrayed. But since the time referred to nothing has
occurred to shake my conviction of the truth of the theory. Let me
briefly state the grounds on which its supporters rely. From their
respective viruses you may plant typhoid fever, scarlatina, or
small-pox. What is the crop that arises from this husbandry? As
surely as a thistle rises from a thistle seed, as surely as the fig
comes from the fig, the grape from the grape, the thorn from the
thorn, so surely does the typhoid virus increase and multiply into
typhoid fever, the scarlatina virus into scarlatina, the small-pox
virus into small-pox. What is the conclusion that suggests itself
here? It is this: That the thing which we vaguely call a virus is to
all intents and purposes a seed. Excluding the notion of vitality, in
the whole range of chemical science you cannot point to an action
which illustrates this perfect parallelism with the phenomena of
life--this demonstrated power of self-multiplication and reproduction.
The germ theory alone accounts for the phenomena.
In cases of epidemic disease, it is not on bad air or foul drains that
the attention of the physician of the future will primarily be fixed,
but upon disease germs, which no bad air or foul drains can create,
but which may be pushed by foul air into virulent energy of
reproduction. You may think I am treading on dangerous ground, that I
am putting forth views that may interfere with salutary practice. No
such thing. If you wish to learn the impotence of medical practice in
dealing with contagious diseases, you have only to refer to the
Harveian oration for 1871, by Sir William Gull. Such diseases defy
the physician. They must run their course, and the utmost that can be
done for them is careful nursing. And this, though I do not specially
insist upon it, would favour the idea of their vital origin. For if
the seeds of contagious disease be themselves living things, it may be
difficult to destroy either them or their progeny, without involving
their living habitat in the same destruction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account