In libraries, public institutions, and very large private collections,
this alphabetical method must almost necessarily be adopted, each plate
being as readily accessible for reference as is a word in a dictionary.
But it involves a large number of albums to allow sufficient room in
each letter for additions, and the plates are all mixed in one
heterogeneous mass, with little regard to age, style, or beauty in
design. In the department of engravings in the Bibliothèque Nationale in
Paris, there are upwards of sixty large volumes full of ex-libris,
arranged alphabetically. This collection was commenced about twenty
years ago, and, under the energetic supervision of M. Georges
Duplessis, it has rapidly increased, and the alphabetical arrangement
has been adopted to facilitate easy reference and comparison.
But M. Henri Bouchot, who, being an official in the print department
there, speaks with authority, remarks that enthusiastic collectors are
also students of history in their special branches, and will (that is,
if their leisure permit) be certain to prefer some more regular and
distinctive system of classification than the simple alphabetical
arrangement.
He therefore recommends the second plan, namely, the division by
countries first, and next, the arrangement in strict chronological
order. There are, however, many difficulties in the way of this
seemingly ideal plan. One may, it is true, soon learn to distinguish,
with a fair amount of accuracy, between French, German, Italian, and
British book-plates; but with other nations the distinctions are less
marked, and Spanish, Dutch, Swiss, or Belgian plates can be easily
confounded with those of their immediate neighbours.
Again, in dealing with plates which have neither name, artist’s
signature, nor date, the chronological subdivisions can only be decided
by a constant comparison of the styles in use at various periods, and by
well-known artists and engravers.
This practice gives the collector a great insight into the progress of
art, and the development of taste, yet it demands both time and patience
to carry it out. Finally, it is true, the collector will have formed a
continuous series of heraldic devices illustrating family history more
completely than can be arrived at in any other manner. It is only by
this constant study and comparison that the student of French ex-libris
can hope to acquire a knowledge of their details, so as to be able to
arrange his collection with a due attention to time, place, and
families.
The third system advocated, namely, the arrangement according to the
styles of the designs on the plates, may be interesting from an artistic
point of view, but is certainly not very methodical.
A collector might divide his French plates under the following heads:
1. _Heraldic._ Subdivided thus: Before 1639. From 1639 to 1789. From
1789 to 1804. From 1804 to the restoration of the Monarchy. Modern
plates. Plates having printed dates to be kept apart from those not
dated.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account