French & English : $b A comparisonHamerton, Philip Gilbert
History
French & English : $b A comparison
Hamerton, Philip Gilbert
National characteristics, English; National characteristics, French
This kind of toleration is not by any means confined to London and
Paris; it has long existed in Italy and Germany. Lewes might have
counted upon it in Liszt, yet at Weimar he asked if he might present
Miss Evans to the musician, not feeling sure “as their position was
irregular.” Liszt himself was living at Weimar with the Princess of
Wittgenstein, who had left her husband for his sake; and the duke had
been so accommodating as to lend them the Altenburg residence, where
they dispensed a graceful hospitality to many friends. The long series
of Liszt’s successes with distinguished ladies did not exclude him from
the world of London and Paris.
[Sidenote: Great Capitals--their Opinion of each Other.]
[Sidenote: Divorce-Court Evidence.]
[Sidenote: Statistics of Prostitution.]
[Sidenote: Clandestine Prostitution.]
Every great capital believes that some other great capital is the most
vicious in the world. London accords that distinction to Paris, Paris
to Vienna, but these accusations are vague, and it is impossible to
know the truth. The evidence in the Divorce Courts reveals a little
of it now and then, and is good evidence so far as it extends, but
it is never published in France. Statistics of prostitution are also
admissible as evidence, but it is difficult to found any comparative
argument upon them; because, in great cities, there is so much
clandestine prostitution, so much eking out of miserable incomes by
that means. The decent, modestly-dressed girl, the sad-looking young
widow whom nobody suspects, may have yielded to the pressure of want.
[Sidenote: The Author’s Unwillingness to believe Evil on Insufficient
Evidence.]
I am unable to follow the English habit of taking French novels as
evidence of the general corruption of French life, and will give good
reasons for this rejection. Before doing so let me observe that I am
equally unwilling to believe evil, on insufficient evidence, of the
English. For example, I have never attached the slightest weight to
what were called the “revelations of the _Pall Mall Gazette_,” which
all the viler French newspapers affected to believe merely because they
would have been, if true, such precious facts for the enemy.
[Sidenote: The English Arguments from French Fiction.]
The English argument usually assumes one of two forms:--
1. Novelists draw from life; consequently, as adultery is almost
universal in French novels it must be equally common in French life.
2. French people purchase novels about adultery in great numbers;
consequently, the readers of these books must commit adultery
themselves.
[Sidenote: Frequency of Crime in Imaginative Literature.]
[Sidenote: Shakespeare.]
[Sidenote: Stories read by the Young.]
[Sidenote: The Suicide Club.]
[Sidenote: Jane Eyre.]
[Sidenote: Adam Bede.]
[Sidenote: Paul Ferroll.]
[Sidenote: Daniel Deronda.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account