The _Débats_, like the _Temps_, is eminently respectable, and never uses
that recognised weapon of French journalism, calumny, which makes the
loss of its prestige on political grounds to be deplored. For, in its
method of fighting its political campaigns, the French Press to-day has
descended to strange depths of dishevelled freedom. Under the Second
Empire the Press had hardly more liberty than that which it enjoyed
under the iron heel of Napoleon, and the supervision exercised by the
censor in songs, plays, pamphlets, and literature was assuredly of
greater benefit to the nation, even when making allowances for errors
of judgment, than the coarse and outrageous licence permitted under the
Third Republic. It was nothing but an act of stupid prudery to have
taken proceedings against a grave masterpiece like _Madame Bovary_, but
the Public Prosecutor, M. Bulot, should certainly have taken measures
to summon before a court of justice M. Octave Mirbeau for writing
such an irredeemable study as _Le Journal d’une Femme de Chambre_.
The working-man, the artisan, those whom the conditions of existence
have excluded from the privileges of education, who can pay only a sou
for their daily supply of political information, cannot be too deeply
pitied for having to rely upon such sources of news as _La Patrie_ and
_L’Intransigeant_. They go into the wine-shop then, primed with the
awful lesson in civilisation they daily receive, their minds poisoned
against all those in public office by the ferocious hate, the slander,
the ignoble lies they have read and discussed in their newspaper. How are
these to distinguish between truth and falsehood? No critical faculties
in them have been cultivated by training or education. They accept as
educated the men who write these pernicious articles, and if the writers
solemnly assure their readers that every public man in France is a thief
and traitor, the latter suppose these men must know, and, being by nature
suspicious of those who rule and tax them, they are only too ready to
believe all they read. And so they credit M. Loubet with a capacity for
every dark crime.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account