From an Easy ChairLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
From an Easy Chair
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history; Science
In November 1906 a Committee appointed by the Government took evidence
as to the desirability of continuing the international investigation
of the North Sea, upon which Great Britain entered five years ago
in conjunction with other Northern States. Only a few weeks before,
a number of scientific experts engaged in this study of the North
Sea, with a view to gaining such knowledge of that great “waste of
waters” as may help the nations of adjacent lands to draw from it
stores of food without destroying the source or recklessly injuring
the supply, were entertained at dinner, at the Guildhall, by the City
Fathers, and treated to speeches by hereditary legislators. The view
expressed by these speakers was that the interests of the great fishing
industry and of the fish trade were best understood by the practical
fisherman. Science was a “handmaid,” useful in her place, but not to
be permitted to undermine established interests and the hoary wisdom
of the practical man, her employer. A German expert of high official
position, one of the guests, took a different line. He was astonished,
even shocked, that Great Britain, the State most largely concerned in
the North Sea fisheries, should be hesitating about continuing to take
part in the international investigation. In Germany, he said, they
took a different course in such matters. Men of business and practical
legislators, when called upon to deal with an important problem, sought
first of all for scientific knowledge of the conditions in question,
as complete and thorough as possible, and then proceeded to act upon
the sure foundation gained. More knowledge, much more knowledge as to
the causes and conditions at work in regard to the life and movements
of fishes in the North Sea was needed. The work of the International
Committee must be continued, and his (the German) Government would
certainly continue to do its share of the work.
The contrast in the British and the German attitude towards science is
what is interesting in this episode. It is true that men of science
in this country have to be content to take a very modest part in
public affairs, and to allow politicians and self-styled “practical”
men to treat science as “a handmaiden”--thankful when science is
not regarded as an enemy. But they know well enough, and those who
are really “practical men” know, that science is no handmaiden, but
in reality the master--the master who must be obeyed; who alone can
give true guidance; who alone can save the State. The sooner and
the more thoroughly the people of this country have recognised this
fact, and insist upon its unqualified acceptance in practice by their
representatives and governors, the better for them and their posterity.
11. _Discoveries as to Malaria_
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account