From an Easy ChairLankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
History
From an Easy Chair
Lankester, E. Ray (Edwin Ray), Sir
Natural history; Science
At this time there had been a revival of the ancient and fanciful
doctrine of “metallic sympathies,” which flourished a hundred years
ago, and was even then but a revival of the strange fancies as to
“sympathetic powders,” which were brought before the Royal Society
by Sir Kenelm Digby at one of its first meetings, in 1660. In the
journal-book of the Royal Society of June 5 of that year, we read,
“Magnetical cures were then discoursed of. Sir Gilbert Talbot promised
to bring in what he knew of sympatheticall cures. Those that had
any powder of sympathy were desired to bring some of it at the next
meeting. Sir Kenelm Digby related that the calcined powder of toades
reverberated, applyed in bagges upon the stomach of a pestiferate
body, cures it by several applications.” The belief in sympathetic
powders and metals was a last survival of the mediæval doctrine of
“signatures,” itself a form of the fetish still practised by African
witch-doctors, and directly connected with the universal system of
magic and witchcraft of European as well as of more remote populations.
To this day, such beliefs lie close beneath the thin crust of modern
knowledge and civilisation, even in England, treasured in obscure
tradition and ready to burst forth in grotesque revivals in all classes
of society. The Royal Society put many of these reputed mechanisms
of witchcraft and magic to the test, and by showing their failure
to produce the effects attributed to them, helped greatly to cause
witches, wizards, and their followers to draw in their horns and
disappear. The germ, however, remained, and reappears in various forms
to-day.
Thirty years ago some of the doctors in Paris believed that a small
disc of gold, or copper, or of silver, laid flat on the arm could
produce an absence of sensation in the arm, and that whilst one person
could be thus affected by one metal another person would respond
only to another metal, according to a supposed “sympathy” or special
affinity of the nervous system for this or that metal. This astonishing
doctrine was thought to be proved by certain experiments made with the
curiously “nervous” (hysterical) women who frequent the Salpêtrière
Hospital as out-patients. That the loss of sensation, which was real
enough, was due to what is called “suggestion”--that is to say, a
belief on the part of the patient that such would be the case, because
the doctor said it would--and had nothing to do with one metal or
another, was subsequently proved by making use of wooden discs in
place of metallic ones, the patient being led to suppose that a disc
of metal of the kind with which she believed herself “sympathetic” was
being applied. Sensation disappeared just as readily as when a special
metallic disc was used.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account