From Ritual to RomanceWeston, Jessie L. (Jessie Laidlay)
Religion
From Ritual to Romance
Weston, Jessie L. (Jessie Laidlay)
Grail -- Legends -- History and criticism; Romances -- History and criticism
In Chapter I, I discussed the task of the hero in general, here I
propose to focus attention upon his host, and while in a measure
traversing the same ground, to do so with a view to determining the
true character of this enigmatic personage.
In the _Bleheris_ version,[1] the lord of the castle is suffering under
no disability whatever; he is described as “tall, and strong of limb,
of no great age, but somewhat bald.” Besides the King there is a Dead
Knight upon a bier, over whose body Vespers for the Dead are solemnly
sung. The wasting of the land, partially restored by Gawain’s question
concerning the Lance, has been caused by the ‘Dolorous Stroke,’ _i.e._,
the stroke which brought about the death of the Knight, whose identity
is here never revealed. Certain versions which interpolate the account
of Joseph of Arimathea and the Grail, allude to ‘Le riche Pescheur’ and
his heirs as Joseph’s descendants, and, presumably, for it is not
directly stated, guardians of the Grail,[2] but the King himself is
here never called by that title. From his connection with the Waste
Land it seems more probable that it was the Dead Knight who filled that
_rôle_.
In the second version of which Gawain is the hero, that of _Diû
Crône_,[3] the Host is an old and infirm man. After Gawain has asked
the question we learn that he is really dead, and only compelled to
retain the semblance of life till the task of the Quester be achieved.
Here, again, he is not called the Fisher King.
In the _Perceval_ versions, on the contrary, we find the name
invariably associated with him, but he is not always directly connected
with the misfortunes which have fallen upon his land. Thus, while the
Wauchier texts are incomplete, breaking off at the critical moment of
asking the question, Manessier who continues, and ostensibly completes,
Wauchier, introduces the Dead Knight, here Goondesert, or Gondefer
(which I suspect is the more correct form), brother of the King, whose
death by treachery has plunged the land in misery, and been the direct
cause of the self-wounding of the King.[4] The healing of the King and
the restoration of the land depend upon Perceval’s slaying the murderer
Partinal. These two versions show a combination of Perceval and Gawain
themes, such as their respective dates might lead us to expect.
Robert de Borron is the only writer who gives a clear, and tolerably
reasonable, account of why the guardian of the Grail bears the title of
Fisher King; in other cases, such as the poems of Chrétien and Wolfram,
the name is connected with his partiality for fishing, an obviously
_post hoc_ addition.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account