Gallio : $b or, The tyranny of science — John Shaqi
Gallio : $b or, The tyranny of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Gallio : $b or, The tyranny of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Science; Science -- Philosophy
according to certain rules, and those rules have excluded these values
from the outset. The life-insurance actuary may, for his purposes,
neglect many things about men, and yet calculate, quite correctly,
what percentage of them will die at forty. But he has not proved that
the qualities he has neglected do not exist simply because they do not
come in to upset his calculations. A politician finds that he has to
base his calculations on quite different aspects of mankind from those
found satisfactory by the actuary. In the same way, a mountain is a
different thing to a poet from what it is to a man of science. For the
kind of understanding of the universe that the man of science is after,
the mountain is merely a heap of certain kinds of matter weighing so
many millions of tons. The poet, who is after a different kind of
vision, finds it necessary to take into account quite other factors
which enter into his total experience of the mountain. The scientist
may also experience emotions of awe and reverence in the presence of
the mountain, but for the purposes of his science these factors of his
experience may be neglected. He _abstracts_ from the total concrete
fact of his experience of the mountain. The mountain, as he describes
it in the scientific paper he proceeds to write, is a mere pale
shadow of the real mountain; he probably leaves it indistinguishable
from any other mountain that happens to weigh the same, just as to
the life-insurance actuary all men of forty are exactly alike. If we
believe that the factors in experience that the scientific man neglects
are quite as real as those he takes into account, it becomes a matter
for wonder that science is possible. How is it that science forms a
closed system――that nothing from the worlds it neglects ever comes in
to disturb it?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account