Gallio : $b or, The tyranny of science — John Shaqi
Gallio : $b or, The tyranny of scienceSullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Philosophy
Gallio : $b or, The tyranny of science
Sullivan, J. W. N. (John William Navin)
Science; Science -- Philosophy
he is not, according to Professor Whitehead, expressing fantasies that
the strong-minded realist can afford to neglect: he is describing
the actual concrete facts of experience, facts which, says Professor
Whitehead, “are distorted in the scientific analysis”. It is the artist
not the scientist who deals most adequately with reality. It is the man
of science, taking his pale abstractions for the only realities, who
dwells in dream-land.
So far as we can see at present, however, science cannot abandon its
method. It cannot deal with the whole concrete fact: it must continue
to make abstractions. But the present _impasse_ in scientific theory
is an indication that it must go back to the beginning and include more
factors of the concrete fact in its abstractions. It seems likely that,
in doing so, it will have to presuppose a philosophy very different
from the materialism hitherto current amongst scientific men. The world
will have to be regarded as an evolutionary process, where “patterns
of value” emerge. It will have to be regarded as an interconnected
whole, and the separation of mind from matter, and mind from mind, will
have to be replaced by a conception which regards these distinctions,
in their present form, as unreal. One very desirable result of this
transformation will be that the arts will be taken seriously. The
old outlook did not regard values as inherent in reality. They were
merely expressive of the accidental human constitution, but had no
cosmic significance. Art existed to provide a unique thrill, called
the “æsthetic emotion”. On the new outlook the function of the arts
is to communicate knowledge and, moreover, the most valuable kind of
knowledge. Art, much more than science, expresses the concrete facts
of experience in their actuality. Music, in particular, finds its
highest function in revealing to us the possibilities of the spirit
of man himself. The music of such a man as Beethoven is a revelation
of existence from the vantage point of a higher consciousness. It is,
we may hope, prophetic of the future development of the race. Not
only art, but morals, acquire vastly greater importance on the new
outlook. Morals are no longer a purely private concern, expressive of a
particular human constitution in an alien, strictly non-moral universe.
Men are no longer justified in believing that their only duty is to
preserve their self-respect and to make the most of their opportunities.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account