Garcia the Centenarian and His Times: Being a Memoir of Manuel Garcia's Life and Labours for the Advancement of Music and ScienceMackinlay, M. (Malcolm) Sterling
History
Garcia the Centenarian and His Times: Being a Memoir of Manuel Garcia's Life and Labours for the Advancement of Music and Science
In this American _première_ of Rossini's "Otello," one of the greatest
successes of the season, we find the parts distributed as follows:--
_Otello_ Signor Garcia.
_Iago_ Signor Garcia (junior).
_Elmiro_ Signor Angrisani.
_Doge_ Signor Crivelli.
_Roderigo_ Madame Barbieri.
_Emilia_ Signora Garcia.
and
_Desdemona_ Signorina Maria Garcia.
It must be many years since any operatic version of "Othello" has been
performed other than that of Verdi, which was produced in Milan exactly
sixty-one years after the performance of Rossini's setting just
described. Indeed at the date of this American _première_, Giuseppe
Verdi was but a lad entering his teens.
Another important production of the season was "Don Giovanni," given on
May 23, with the elder Garcia in the title-_rôle_. His son appeared as
Leporello, and, as the criticism in 'The Albion' stated four days later:
"In the part of Saporello"--the office shines once more in
spelling--"the younger Garcia exhibited more musical ability than he has
been generally thought to possess. His duet with Don Giovanni in the
banquet scene was spirited enough."
Some other portions of this critique read rather quaintly. It will be
remembered how the editor of the paper was perturbed after the opening
performance of the season at not receiving the "scientific critique,
which we are promised from a professor." He is evidently "still harping
on my daughter," for one reads with infinite regret that--"To enter into
any minute examination of 'Don Giovanni's' _scientific_ merits is beyond
our space and purpose"; while later we learn that "Madame Barbiere's
taste is pure, and her _science_ considerable."
The critic comes to the regrettable conclusion that "Garcia Senior is
not at home in the simple melodies of Mozart," the reason which he gives
for this fact being set forth in a delightful bit of phraseology,--"He
must have a wide field for display: he must have ample room to verge
enough for unlimited curvetings and flourishes."
Maria was able to satisfy this most learned and scientific judge, and we
may presume that she found sufficiency of verging-room in Mozart, for we
are told, "Mdlle. Garcia's Zerlina, though not so simple and rustic as
Fador's (_sic_), the great Zerlina of Europe, is much more pleasing and
fascinating. It was admirably acted, which for a singer is high praise.
The celebrated 'Batti, batti,' was never better sung."
"In proportion as she is excellent," the notice concludes, "must we
regret that a few nights longer and she will disappear from the public
gaze."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account