Geographic Variation in the North American Cyprinid Fish, Hybopsis gracilisCross, Frank B. (Frank Bernard)
Science
Geographic Variation in the North American Cyprinid Fish, Hybopsis gracilis
Cross, Frank B. (Frank Bernard)
Cyprinidae; Fishes -- North America
Variation in _H. gracilis_, as shown in the graphic analysis (Figs. 1
and 2) and distribution map (Plate 21), presents two clines: a
north-south cline and a large-river to small-river (mainly east-west)
cline. The absence of _H. gracilis_ from certain portions of river
systems is a matter of concern. The species has not been found in the
lower Arkansas River and the Rio Grande, nor in sandy tributary creeks
in eastern Kansas and Missouri that appear to provide suitable habitat.
It has already been noted that _H. g. gulonella_ seems to be the
ecological equivalent of _Semotilus atromaculatus_ in streams in which
_S. atromaculatus_ is not found. _S. atromaculatus_ occurs in creeks of
eastern Kansas and Missouri, and may provide interspecific competition
that prevents establishment of the flathead chub in these creeks.
Regardless of cause, the gaps in distribution of _H. gracilis_ tend to
limit gene flow.
Many characters used in the separation of the two subspecies are known
to be influenced by environmental conditions, especially temperature.
Hubbs (1922, 1926, 1941), Schultz (1927), Vladykov (1934), Taning (1952)
and Weisel (1955), among others, have pointed out a correlation between
temperature (or developmental rate of fish) and the number of vertebrae,
scales, and fin-rays. Likewise, Martin (1949) and Hart (1952) have shown
that the proportions of some body-parts vary in response to temperature
during early development. In _H. gracilis_, the general nature of the
clines found in a majority of characters (but not all characters)
suggests a temperature influence. However, temperature-dependent
variability that has so far been demonstrated experimentally in fishes
is generally of lesser magnitude than the differences distinguishing _H.
g. gracilis_ and _H. g. gulonella_. To our knowledge, the most extreme
differences that have been induced by modification of temperature are
those reported for _Salmo trutta_ by Taning (1952:181-182), who states:
"Shock treatment produced by especially great changes in temperature
(_c._ 10-14 deg. C), especially during the super-sensitive period [of
somatic differentiation that fixes vertebral number] may produce ... a
difference of 3-4 vertebrae ... in offspring of the same parents." The
difference cited approximates that which distinguishes natural
populations of _H. g. gracilis_ and _H. g. gulonella_. Although we
cannot assume that the sensitivity of the brown trout is the same as
that of the flathead chub, the causative conditions in Taning's study
could scarcely be expected in nature; furthermore, it seems significant
that extremely high (as well as extremely low) mean numbers of scales
and vertebrae were found at southern localities, and that low mean
numbers of scales and vertebrae were found as far north as Wyoming and
Montana. We think it likely that temperature does influence the
expression of characters in _H. gracilis_, directly in individual
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account