Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
Many years ago the superstition crept into Germany that Shakespeare
must be given literally word for word, even if actors and audience
were murdered in the process. The attempts, occasioned by an excellent
and exact translation, were nowhere successful, of which fact the
painstaking and repeated endeavors of the stage at Weimar are the best
witness. If we wish to see a Shakespearean play, we must take up again
Schroeder’s version; but the notion that in the staging of Shakespeare
not an iota may be omitted, senseless as it is, one hears constantly
repeated. If the defenders of this opinion maintain the upper hand, in
a few years Shakespeare will be quite driven from the stage, which for
that matter would be no great misfortune; for then the reader, whether
he be solitary or sociable, will be able to get so much the purer
pleasure out of him.
They have, however, with the idea of making an attempt along the lines
of which we have spoken in detail above, revised _Romeo and Juliet_
for the theatre at Weimar. The principles according to which this was
done we shall develop before long, and it will perhaps become apparent
why this version, whose staging is by no means difficult, although it
must be handled artistically and carefully, did not take on the German
stage. Attempts of a similar kind are going on, and perhaps something
is preparing for the future, for frequent endeavors do not always show
immediate effects.
FOOTNOTES:
[8] “Goethe, in a thoughtful essay, _Shakespeare und kein
Ende_, written many years later than his famous criticism of Hamlet in
_Wilhelm Meister_, says that the distinction between the two [ancient
and modern drama] is the difference between _sollen_ and _wollen_,
that is, between _must_ and _would_. He means that in the Greek drama
the catastrophe is foreordained by an inexorable Destiny, while the
element of free will, and consequently choice, is the very axis of
the modern. The definition is conveniently portable, but it has its
limitations. Goethe’s attention was too exclusively fixed on the fate
tragedies of the Greeks, and upon Shakespeare among the moderns. In the
Spanish drama, for example, custom, loyalty, honor, and religion are as
imperative and as inevitable as doom. In the _Antigone_, on the other
hand, the crisis lies in the character of the protagonist.”--James
Russell Lowell, _Shakespeare Once More_.
FIRST EDITION OF _HAMLET_
(1827)
_The First Edition of the Tragedy of Hamlet_, by William Shakespeare,
London, 1603. Reprinted by Fleischer, Leipzig, 1825.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account