Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in EnglishGoethe, Johann Wolfgang von
History
Goethe's literary essays : $b A selection in English
Goethe, Johann Wolfgang von
Art; Literature -- History and criticism
“I do not find it specially expressed; but, by comparison of passages,
I think it incontestable. The fencing tires him; the sweat is
running from his brow; and the Queen remarks, ‘_He’s fat, and scant
of breath._’ Can you conceive him to be otherwise than plump and
fair-haired? Brown-complexioned people, in their youth, are seldom
plump. And does not his wavering melancholy, his soft lamenting, his
irresolute activity, accord with such a figure? From a dark-haired
young man, you would look for more decision and impetuosity.”
“You are spoiling my imagination,” cried Aurelia; “away with your fat
Hamlets! Do not set your well-fed prince before us! Give us rather any
_succedancum_ that will move us, will delight us. The intention of the
author is of less importance to us than our own enjoyment, and we need
a charm that is adapted for us.”
* * * * *
One evening a dispute arose among our friends about the novel and the
drama, and which of them deserved the preference. Serlo said it was a
fruitless and misunderstood debate: both might be superior in their
kinds, only each must keep within the limits proper to it.
“About their limits and their kinds,” said Wilhelm, “I confess myself
not altogether clear.”
“Who _is_ so?” said the other; “and yet perhaps it were worth while to
come a little closer to the business.”
They conversed together long upon the matter; and, in fine, the
following was nearly the result of their discussion:--
“In the novel as well as in the drama, it is human nature and human
action that we see. The difference between these sorts of fiction lies
not merely in their outward form,--not merely in the circumstance that
the personages of the one are made to speak, while those of the other
have commonly their history narrated. Unfortunately many dramas are but
novels which proceed by dialogue; and it would not be impossible to
write a drama in the shape of letters.
“But, in the novel, it is chiefly _sentiments_ and _events_ that are
exhibited; in the drama, it is _characters_ and _deeds_. The novel
must go slowly forward; and the sentiments of the hero, by some means
or another, must restrain the tendency of the whole to unfold itself
and to conclude. The drama, on the other hand, must hasten; and the
character of the hero must press forward to the end: it does not
restrain, but is restrained. The novel-hero must be suffering,--at
least he must not in a high degree be active; in the dramatic one, we
look for activity and deeds. Grandison, Clarissa, Pamela, the Vicar
of Wakefield, Tom Jones himself, are, if not suffering, at least
retarding, personages; and the incidents are all in some sort modeled
by their sentiments. In the drama the hero models nothing by himself;
all things withstand him; and he clears and casts away the hindrances
from off his path, or else sinks under them.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account