Gout, with a section on ocular disease in the goutyLlewellyn, Llewellyn J. (Llewellyn Jones)
Science
Gout, with a section on ocular disease in the gouty
Llewellyn, Llewellyn J. (Llewellyn Jones)
Eye -- Diseases; Gout
Apart from its intrinsic fascination, the tracing out of analogies,
clinical or pathological, between diseases apparently diverse has often
proved a fruitful source of enlightenment, for the natural history of
disease is such that one disorder trenches upon the clinical territory of
another, symptoms overlap and similarity if not community of origin is
revealed.
Few will gainsay that gouty individuals are the victims of some inborn
defect or eccentricity of metabolism, and instinctively the thought
arises, are there no other disorders of like character? Immediately
we bethink ourselves of alkaptonuria, cystinuria and pentosuria. Sir
Archibald Garrod, as we know, classed these disorders as “chemical
malformation” of hereditary origin. In other words, all are the outcome
of an abnormality in intermediary metabolism.
In alkaptonuria the metabolic warp concerns the _aromatic_ groups, in
cystinuria the sulphur-containing radicles of the _protein_ molecule.
On the other hand, in pentosuria the origin of the endogenous pentose
is variously ascribed to the _nucleo-protein_ of the cell nuclei or to
galactose. Lastly, in gout it is in the metabolism of _nucleo-protein_,
or rather of the _nucleic acids_ of the cell nuclei that the flaw resides.
We see, therefore, that Langdon Brown, discussing gout, is well justified
in observing that, “We may look upon a person who is readily poisoned by
purins in the same light as the person who has cystinuria, alkaptonuria,
or pentosuria, _i.e._, they all lack a link in the chain of protein
katabolism, so that intermediate products appear in the urine instead of
the usual end-products.” In other words, they all display a pathological
kinship, viz., in that they are all due to inborn errors of metabolism.
Certain broad clinical resemblances also obtain. All members of the
group, including gout, display _hereditary_ tendencies. All occur much
more often in _males_ than in females. They all alike tend to persist
through life. Lastly, their distinctive chemical products, including uric
acid, are all apparently of _low toxicity_.
But when we pass to the realm of their symptomatology, resemblance, if it
does not cease, becomes relatively obscured. Cystinuria and pentosuria
appear to be “harmless anomalies,” and the same is true of alkaptonuria.
The cystinuric, albeit, does suffer with _urinary_ concretions, and we
may recall that some authorities hold that gout and uric acid _calculi_
are not unrelated. As to alkaptonuria, it has this attenuated link
with gout that in its later stages the victims thereof tend to develop
a degenerative type of _arthritis_, while the frequently associated
pigmentary change, _ochronosis_, has a predilection for deposition in the
cartilages of the ears and _joints_.
But how colourless the clinical features of alkaptonuria, etc., as
contrasted with the vivid arresting phenomena of gout! how remote the
latter disorder from these “harmless anomalies”!
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account