Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 3, September 1841 — John Shaqi
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 3, September 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 3, September 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Our retiring habits, in this particular, being thus understood, it will
be seen at once that we have no design of arguing the point with the Old
Song which we have quoted at the head of this paper. We cannot undertake
to support the pretensions of the “flowery lea” against those of the
“chimney corner.” In the case of hill-side versus ingle-side we beg
leave to keep aloof. We do not say with the blue-bean gentlemen that
there is much to be said on _both_ sides of the question; for the truth
is we perceive at a glance that the subject has a wonderful variety of
aspects, each highly important and interesting, and upon every one of
which we could preach a very excellent sermon if occasion required. At a
first view there is only the ordinary double-sided question, whether the
ingle-side be preferable to the hill-side, or the hill-side to the
ingle. But then we have at once in continuation, the concomitant
sub-queries whether the hill-side be a hill-side of donkey-thistle or of
purple heather—whether there be sheep on it or snakes—whether it be
winter or summer—whether it be a rainy day or a sun-shiny one—whether
the ingle be smoky or not smoky—whether, in the latter case, we choose
to be cured like bacon or be left uncured—whether wood or coal be
burnt, and whether, if coal, you have any tendency to what Dr.
Blunderbuzzard calls pulmonary phthisis.
Now each of these sub-queries involves a point of especial importance,
and each of these points must be definitely settled, before we begin to
make up our minds on the main one, and the worst of it is that each of
these points, too, may be subdivided into I cannot tell how many others,
all equally momentous, if not more so, and every one of them to be fully
discussed and permanently decided upon, before we can do anything at all
towards drawing a judicious conclusion. So that in the end we lose both
our way, and our labor, and are forced, in respect to the matter of this
song, to fall back upon one of those very rare questions which have
really but two sides, and base our final decision upon that. This
question is simply whether the lady who sings the song, be pretty or
ugly. The only difficulty about this mode of forming an opinion is that
the opinion itself is apt to have something of a variable character—but
then it would be no fashionable opinion if it had not.
At present we decide against the lea and give judgment for “The
Fireside.”
* * * * *
FRAGMENT: WRITTEN ON THE FIRST COMING OF SPRING.
BY PARK BENJAMIN.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account