Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 5, November 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XIX, No. 5, November 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
Miss Leslie is celebrated for the homely naturalness of her stories and
for the broad satire of her comic style. She has written much for the
Magazines. Her chirography is distinguished for neatness and finish,
without over-effeminacy. It is rotund, and somewhat diminutive; the
letters being separate, and the words always finished with an inward
twirl. She is never particular about the quality of her paper or the
other externals of epistolary correspondence. From her MSS. in general,
we might suppose her solicitous rather about the effect of her
compositions as a whole, than about the polishing of the constituent
parts. There is much of the picturesque both in her chirography and in
her literary style.
[Illustration: signature of Joseph C. Neal]
Mr. Neal has acquired a very extensive reputation through his “Charcoal
Sketches,” a series of papers originally written for the “Saturday
News,” of this city, and afterwards published in book form, with
illustrations by Johnston. The whole design of the “Charcoal Sketches”
may be stated as the depicting of the wharf and street _loafer_; but
this design has been executed altogether in caricature. The extreme of
burlesque runs throughout the work, which is, also, chargeable with a
tedious repetition of slang and incident. The loafer always declaims the
same nonsense, in the same style, gets drunk in the same way, and is
taken to the watch-house after the same fashion. Reading one chapter of
the book, we read all. Any single description would have been an
original idea well executed, but the dose is repeated _ad nauseam_, and
betrays a woful poverty of invention. The manner in which Mr. Neal’s
book was belauded by his personal friends of the Philadelphia press,
speaks little for their independence, or less for their taste. To dub
the author of these “Charcoal Sketches” (which are really very excellent
police-reports) with the title of “the American Boz,” is either
outrageous nonsense, or malevolent irony.
In other respects, Mr. N. has evinced talents which cannot be
questioned. He has conducted the “Pennsylvanian” with credit, and, as a
political writer, he stands deservedly high. His MS. is simple and
legible, with much space between the words. It has force, but little
grace. Altogether, his chirography is good; but as he belongs to the
editorial corps, it would not be just to suppose that any deductions, in
respect to character, could be gleaned from it. His signature conveys
the general MS. with accuracy.
[Illustration: signature of Seba Smith]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account